Replies: 21 Unseemly Comments
All time fav. movie musicals:
Li'l Abner!! -- just fun and everyone from Leslie Parish to Stubby Kaye are so memorable
Singin' in the Rain!! - the quintessential movie musical
Seven Brides for Seven Brothers!! Charming and fun. Love the dancing and the lyrical wit.
and Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. I think it was everyone's dream as a child to be invited into a chocolate factory... and I think that Pure Imagination is one of Leslie Bricusse's best work
and I would like to make note of Frank Oz's Little Shop of Horrors which was deftly executed with wonderful performances and although it played larger, it was still quite intimate on the screen.
Posted by Craig @ 02/20/2002 10:03 AM PST
"Singing in the Rain" and "Seven Brides," of course, but I also have a special fondness for "Yankee Doodle Dandy" (Jimmy Cagney on the pier after the skyrocket goes off is pure magic), "The Jolson Story" (total fantasy but Parks makes it work), "The Court Jester" (Danny Kaye at his best) and any of Fred Astaire's RKO musicals (especially "Top Hat" and "Swingtime").
Other favorites include Betty Garrett in "My Sister Eileen," Jessie Matthews in several of her British musicals (what a shame she was cheated out of her chance to work with Astaire), and Doris Day singing and Vera-Ellen dancing in almost anything.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 02/20/2002 11:36 AM PST
Fave Film Musical: An American in Paris, because whenever they're singing and/or dancing, they don't pretend to NOT be singing and/or dancing, and everyone in the background stops to watch, just as we all would if someone started singing and dancing on the street. And there's almost always a visual source for the music: Oscar Levant's magic piano (the one with the orchestra inside).
Posted by Pam @ 02/20/2002 11:47 AM PST
Robert -
Of course.. the Court Jester... excellent choice!
Posted by Craig @ 02/20/2002 11:47 AM PST
First of all, welcome to new dear reader Megan, who made a post for yesterday's notes which went up too late for most of you to see it.
Second, I forgot to mention my fave screen musicals: Singin' In The Rain, Swing Time, West Side Story (sorry, I LOVE it and there's nothing you can do about it), The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, and two that have already been mentioned, The Court Jester and Li'l Abner. I'm also fond of The Jolson Story (just for the great Jolie singing) and The Sound of Music.
Posted by bk @ 02/20/2002 11:59 AM PST
Glad you mentioned "The Sound of Music," though, like "Lawrence of Arabia," it is best viewed on a BIG screen. An absolutely gorgeous movie. Love "Cherbourg" and "Abner," too, but have always been cranky about all of the lyric changes in "West Side Story." Of course anything with Natalie Wood is worth watching, although, as with Karen Carpenter, her performances generally make me feel melancholy. What a loss!
Posted by Robert Armin @ 02/20/2002 12:12 PM PST
Oh.. I neglected to mention some kids classics:
The Muppet Movie -- for it's childlike quality, Little Mermaid and Beauty and the Beast and a closet favorite that probably very few even remember: Raggedy Ann and Andy: A Musical Adventure, which I am sure will sadly never see DVD as the animation is really bad, but Joe Raposo's songs were nothing short of brilliant.. especially his song "Blue" sung by the camel, and "Candy Hearts and Paper Flowers" sung by both Ann and Andy as they comfort each other in the deep dark woods...
Posted by Craig @ 02/20/2002 12:15 PM PST
Craig --
Haven't seen the movie of "Raggedy Ann and Andy" but I did get to see one of the 20 Broadway performances! The other kid films you mentioned are all great including "Willy Wonka." I also like "5000 Fingers of Dr. T" and "The Muppets Take Manhattan." On the latter film, I operated several of the "background" muppets during the wedding sequence. Jim Henson was a terrific human being (and, along with Wood and Carpenter, another tragic loss) and Frank Oz was already a first-rate director.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 02/20/2002 12:35 PM PST
I adore a 1942 wartime musical called "Thank your lucky stars". Lot's of wonderfully silly Eddie Cantor songs and Bette Davis sings "They're either too old or too young." Just fabu
Lately I have been watching Bollywood musicals in Hindi. "Kuch Kuch Hota Hai" and "Taal" are fantastic! The songs and costumes really make them.
Posted by Matt @ 02/20/2002 12:46 PM PST
Robert-
Awesome.. love the muppets..always have. I was a PA for a few of their PSA's about the environment many many years ago. Wow.. so did the bway version of RA&A use the Raposo songs? Intriguing.. I always thought that it would make a great show -- maybe a revival is due with a rewrite! I'd even settle for a CD issue of the film score... I drive around with one that I burned off an old LP. Interesting to note the theatre notables that provided voices in that, including Sheldon Harnick, Mark Linn Baker, George S. Irving, Mason Adams...
As for 5000 fingers... I heard this was in heavy development for a bway run in the future...
Posted by Craig @ 02/20/2002 12:50 PM PST
Oh -- one last favorite: Louis Armstrong, Danny Kaye and little Susan Gordon singing their counterpart "Goodnight, Sleep Tight" medley in "The Five Pennies," although the number was better (and not truncated) on the soundtrack album. And on top of everything else, that girl grew up to be Tuesday Weld!
Posted by Robert Armin @ 02/20/2002 12:51 PM PST
WOW!! So many comments,,,Beside SINGIN IN THE RAIN.My personal faves are THE BANDWAGON...PENNIES FROM HEAVEN...and recently MOULIN ROUGE.And how about A STAR IS BORN?
Posted by Arnold M. Brockman @ 02/20/2002 01:28 PM PST
The Dr. T musical in development (for years) has an original score and doesn't use any of the Dr. Seuss/Fredrick Hollander songs from the film. Those songs are absolutely fascinating - The Dressing Song is one of the most surreal musical numbers ever (I included it on one of the Michelle Nicastro albums), and Because We're Kids is beautiful.
Posted by bk @ 02/20/2002 02:23 PM PST
Some of my faves (along with favorite quotes):
FUNNY FACE: "I don't want to stop, I like it! Take the picture! Take the picture!"
HIGH SOCIETY: "You must be one of the newer fellas..."
GIGI: "The only people who make love all the time are liars."
I frequently pepper my conversation with these (and other) quotes, causing many people to look at me as if I just escaped from the big white van... heehee...
Posted by Stacie @ 02/20/2002 02:24 PM PST
I once walked by MRS. Dr. Seuss on a West Hollywood street by her house, which was all black stucco. I did not know that the strange creature, dressed entirely in black and with the weirdest bun of a hairdo I've ever seen (and whom my then two-year-old son shrank from in terror) was MRS. Dr. Seuss until I went back to the restaurant where my family had been eating, and I mentioned that I had passed the strangest looking woman I had ever seen by the strangest black stucco house I had ever seen. The waitress then informed that she was "Mrs. Geisel." Suddenly, I knew where the inspiration for the look of the Cat in the Hat came from. Oh, and my favorite film musical, just because I was at a very impressionable age when I saw it at a Cinerama theater (though I think it was just a regular old 70mm print if I recall), is "Sweet Charity".
Posted by JMK @ 02/20/2002 02:58 PM PST
I can't believe nobody's said The Wizard of Oz.
Posted by Lulu @ 02/20/2002 07:12 PM PST
My favorite movie musicals (and what is better than an actually GOOD movie musical??) ARE:
The Wizard of Oz
Willy Wonka
West Side Story
Victor/Victoria
Singing in the Rain
The Sound of Music
My Fair Lady (I know what you're thinking and I'm sticking out my tongue.)
The Music Man
The King & I
Okay, that's enough for now, I think. :)
Posted by Lolita @ 02/20/2002 07:35 PM PST
Best Film Adaptation of a Broadway Musical that Stuck to the Source: The Music Man.
Best Film Adaptation of a Broadway Musical that Didn't Stick to the Source but Made for Boffo Film: Cabaret.
Best Film Musical with Music from Other Sources: Singin' In the Rain.
Best Film Musical, Original Score: South Park, Bigger, Longer, & Uncut.
Best Film Musical Based on the Score but I Still Haven't Seen the Film, Don't Know Why: Swing Time. (I still haven't seen this one? Shame on me! And I'm a Dorothy Fields fan!)
Posted by SWoodyWhite @ 02/20/2002 11:05 PM PST
So close to 20 posts.. which I know Bruce would smile about.. I just had to agreee with The Music Man..
Posted by Craig @ 02/21/2002 06:10 AM PST
The Music Man rocks, and Robert Preston is god.
If only I could go back in time and make them rethink the whole Buddy Hackett thing...
Posted by Lulu @ 02/21/2002 06:47 AM PST
I'm not much for watching movies, but I liked Fiddler on the Roof, Music Man, Seven Brides, Sound of Music, and Muppett Movies.
Posted by Laura @ 02/21/2002 12:27 PM PST