Replies: 17 Unseemly Comments
I have an answer to the trivia question: Harvey Schmidt, who was an acclaimed illustrator prior to the opening of his first show, the acclaimed and hard-to-believe-now-closed "The Fantasticks." He continued to illustrate many things over the years -- logo designs and posters for "Fantasticks," "Celebration," the Ben Bagley albums and, most recently, the album cover for "The Fantasticks in Jazz," produced by the one and only Bruce Kimmel.
Posted by Phil Crosby @ 03/04/2002 08:49 AM PST
Ah, to hear Mr. Haines's five note voice wrap around the sultry strains of Ernest and Meltz! An excellent notion, as it appears that all major recordings of this unjustly-forgotten duo (including the legendary "Merman is Meltz-ing" and Mandy Patinkin's "Meltz-a-loshen" album, in which he performs all four parts of "Stop Kvetching now, Melvin!") are now out of print, and Footlight records will not even acknowledge my repeated requests.
A book with a soundtrack? Sounds intriguing. I am now intrigued. Would I purchase such an item? Quite possibly, if 'twere at a reasonable price.
Posted by Elan @ 03/04/2002 09:02 AM PST
Well, I feel so much better now that Phil has messed up the trivia quiz, thereby letting me off the hook as the ONLY one to similarly do so. I'm glad I submitted the correct answer last night!
As for the various and sundried (like Presidents) ideas for new CDs, you know I'll buy practically anything with Guy's name on it. (I'm still responsbile for nearly 1/3 of all of the monetary contributions to this site.)
Cereally, though, why not call some of your recording star buddies and put together a new CD on the cheap. A sort of benefit CD, as it were. Call in all those old favors and favor us with a super-limited edition collector's item goodie. One that will sell next year on eBay for a fortune. Go Guy!
Posted by Robert Armin @ 03/04/2002 10:03 AM PST
Well, I'll be hornswaggled (but not publicly)! I would surely buy a Meltz and Ernest album! As for the book with cd? Hmmm...possibly.
By the way, thank you BK for introducing me to the music of Oscar Brown Jr. I bought Sin and Soul and I am transfixed!! Ab Fab!
Posted by Mattso @ 03/04/2002 10:17 AM PST
Well, that's a big fat YES to both cd ideas.
As far as my revival: I'd revive On a Clear Day You Can See Forever and star Faith Prince (I know she's a bit old, but who really cares?) as Daisy, Matthew Broderick as the Doc, Robert Sean Leonard (I liked him in the music man) as Warren, and Craig Beirko as The Hunk of Old.
Okay, age-wise is sucks, but it's my fantasy.
Posted by Lolita @ 03/04/2002 11:03 AM PST
Your toying with ideas has me quite excited, indeed! I fully intend to buy your book as soon as it's available, and a companion CD just sounds perfectly swell. And I do agree that a Meltz and Ernest CD is long overdue. I can see that this site is going to be the ruin of my meager student budget!!!
Posted by Jed @ 03/04/2002 11:07 AM PST
I would happily buy a Meltz-Ernest CD, assuming that their music is as good as their lyrics. It would delight me to no end.
Posted by Hapgood @ 03/04/2002 01:01 PM PST
Oh to add to the Guy Haines collection! I would certainly be interested in purchasing Guy singing almost anything. The CD plus book sounds a great idea. Oz author Tim Winton had a similar idea with his recent book "Dirt Music". SUCCESSFUL idea it was too.
Posted by Tom Guest @ 03/04/2002 01:12 PM PST
Oh, my goodness, our very own dear reader, Mr. Phil Crosby has spilled the beans, oh, yes, beans have been spilled and there are no two or even three ways about it. So, only guesses that arrived prior to his post will be counted. I guess I shall have to spell out the rules for answering the trivia question in each and every contest. Meanwhile, Mr. Phil Crosby shouldn't feel too bad, we love and adore him no matter what he did. He will, of course, have to be bitch-slapped by Mr. Mark Bakalor, but that isn't an altogether unpleasant experience.
Posted by bk @ 03/04/2002 01:16 PM PST
Oh, my. I would simply love to have Mr. Haines sing the hits of Meltzer and Ernest. Do you think he could be convinced to record it?
So if both these ideas come to being, my Christmas gift ideas for the next two years will be complete!
Posted by Laura @ 03/04/2002 02:09 PM PST
I wonder what would happen if Guy sent some of the Meltz and Ernest songs to people like Sondheim, Ebb, Herman, Schmidt and their other musical theatre colleagues and asked them to do "arrangements" of the material. Might make an interesting album. And heaven knows, they owe Guy the favor.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 03/04/2002 05:09 PM PST
What a fabulous idea: two spankin'-new CD's sung by the one-and-only Guy Haines! I would surely love to hear Guy sing those wonderfully brilliant Ernest and Meltz songs, as well as the sure-to-be-revived songs memorialized in Bruce Kimmel's 'Benjamin Kritzer.' What a combination: Bruce and Guy and Benjamin!
Posted by sg @ 03/04/2002 05:50 PM PST
I proudly own the Guy Haines cd, and would kill to have two more.... anytime, anywhere...
Posted by Robbie Rozelle @ 03/04/2002 08:48 PM PST
I'll buy it all!
Posted by kerry @ 03/04/2002 09:14 PM PST
I want all the cds, and I want them YESTERDAY!!!!
Guy Haines RULES!
Posted by td @ 03/04/2002 09:27 PM PST
It is well known that I am sick enough to buy anything with Bruce Kimmel's name on it, so count me as a future purchaser.
As for revivals, how about staging KEAN with Brian Stokes Mitchell and Marin Mazzie? It actually has the best setting of the Willow Song from OTHELLO that I have ever heard. This must certainly be the only musical based on a work by Paul Sartre and his lovely wife Jean.
Perhaps Tom Stoppard could rewrite the book a bit. ("He's not apologizing, Your Highness, he's having Marlowe do it for him.")
Best line in the show: "You don't *pay* creditors--you *owe* them!"
Posted by William F. Orr @ 03/05/2002 05:26 AM PST
In answer to Armin's post of a couple of days ago, viz.:
"My wife, Kristine Nevins, was in the Bye Bye Birdie with Tommy Tune and Marc Kudisch (as Conrad). Duane may have been in the subsequent non-Equity tour."
Since Marc Kudisch was born in 1966, and I saw the BIRDIE national company to which I referred in 1960, that would be a neat trick indeed. :-)
I keep forgetting that not all musical theatre fans are as ancient as Bruce and I.
Posted by William F. Orr @ 03/05/2002 05:45 AM PST