Replies: 16 Unseemly Comments
Ah, Comden & Green! I directed the NYC revival of Say, Darling and reintroduced some long lost C&G songs, including three from Two On The Aisle (including "If"). "Some Other Time" from On The Town is probably they're most perfect song, although "The Party's Over" is a close runner-up. Again, too many to choose from. One esoteric choice -- "I Like Myself" from It's Always Fair Weather.
Yesterday, Tom from Oz prompted me to listen to the Cape Man cast album for the first time since the show closed. The score, separate from the show, is actually quite listenable. On stage, the lyrics were trite and often redundant -- the actors just stood there and TOLD you who they were in a manner that was much too self-knowing. Imagine if Billy Bigelow had sung:
My name is Billy Bigelow
I'm a barker on a Carousel.
I'm a cad but the young girls come to ride.
One chick named Julie really looks swell.
On record, though, Cape Man's lyrics help to separate one character from another and they TELL you the story more than most scores do. Unfortunately, if DreamWorks finally releases the 2-CD cast album it might prompt more stage productions, and I doubt that any production will ever work. We are asked to sympathize with a man who murders an innocent person and then expects our sympathy because he writes nice poetry in prison. Sorry, no matter how tough his upbringing, the guy isn't worth our attention. Just my three cents.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 03/17/2002 09:28 AM PST
Of course, I meant "their most perfect song" and not "they're most perfect song." Although they ARE, in combination, a perfect song, figuratively speaking.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 03/17/2002 09:59 AM PST
I have not one, but two, synchronicities for you today (I know you eagerly await these, yes, I'm quite sure of it). First, you may not believe it, but I could easily prove it to you if you were to drop my home, but I have collected Saturday Evening Posts since I was a kid. I have them going back to the early 20th century. I actually wrote part of a musical when I was in my teen years about the Saturday Evening Post (not as unlikely a subject as you may think), called "Saturday's Child." Have you read Otto Friedrich's exceptional "Decline and Fall", about the, well, decline and fall of that mag? Fascinating. Synchronicity #2: I am Irish-Jewish. Now some people claim this cannot be, but I can assure you my paternal grandmother was an Irish Jew from Dublin. And if memory serves, I believe the former mayor of Dublin, Teddy Krolick, or something like that, was Jewish. So today's Meltz/Ernest wonderment is just especially meaningful to me.
Oy, begorrah, how I go on! Anyway, my favorite Comden/Green is another ballad I can't understand why more jazz people haven't covered: "Talking to Yourself," from Hallelujah, Baby!
Posted by JMK @ 03/17/2002 12:45 PM PST
Thanks Robert. Never been to keen on the story line of Capeman but the Paul Simon album had such treasures. Wondered if the full score had more. Would love to hear another Paul Simon score for Broadway but guess it will never happen now. Appreciate the note.
On to Comden & Green. "Some Other Time" is wonderful. "My Own Morning" is also a favourite.
Posted by Tom from Oz @ 03/17/2002 01:41 PM PST
Thanks Robert. Never been to keen on the story line of Capeman but the Paul Simon album had such treasures. Wondered if the full score had more. Would love to hear another Paul Simon score for Broadway but guess it will never happen now. Appreciate the note.
On to Comden & Green. "Some Other Time" is wonderful. "My Own Morning" is also a favourite.
Posted by Tom from Oz @ 03/17/2002 01:41 PM PST
Isn't it interesting that St. Patrick wasn't actually Irish? Sounds like Hollywood, doesn't it?
My favorite Comden and Green is certainly Some Other Time, though I love Just In Time and The Party's Over.
Posted by Lolita @ 03/17/2002 03:31 PM PST
"Never Never Land," "Long Before I Knew You," "It's A prefect Relationship" and one of my choices for Cy Coleman also- "My Big Mistake." I also like "Moses Supposes" from "Singing in the Rain." Congratulations, Bruce, on the paintings!
Posted by Kerry @ 03/17/2002 05:10 PM PST
I knew I was forgetting something. "I Just Can't Wait" and "Be A Santa."
Posted by Kerry @ 03/17/2002 05:12 PM PST
In no particular order
Can You Hear Me Now? (A Doll's Life which was later dropped in the revision.)
Our Private World & The Legacy (On the 20th Century)
Make Someone Happy (Do Re Mi)
The Party's Over & Long Before I Knew You (Bells Are Ringing)
The Intermission's Great & Some Other Time (The former Cut from On the Town)
A Quiet Girl (Wonderful Town)
Distant Melody & Never Never Land (Peter Pan)
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 03/17/2002 05:28 PM PST
Sure and how can ya be thinkin' of any other song but "My Darlin' Eileen", it bein' what day it is and all?
Posted by William F. Orr @ 03/17/2002 06:12 PM PST
Adventure-Do Re Mi (This song has become almost a catch-phrase in our family. We'll sing it at the drop of a hat.)
The Wrong Note Rag-Wonderful Town
Both great comedy songs.
All of my Life-also Do Re Mi. Very moving.
Why is it that St. Patrick's day is the only holiday when everyone becomes the nationality that celebrates it? Why, for instance, are we not all French on Bastille Day? Muslim during Ramadan? Mexican on Cinco de Mayo? Canadian on Boxing Day? To name just a few.
An interesting question to ponder indeed.
Posted by Hapgood @ 03/17/2002 06:56 PM PST
Ah, "On the Twentieth Century," giving us "Life is Like a Train," "Babette," "I've Got It All." John Cullum sat in the row behind der Brucer and me one time, on a flight from New York to Los Angeles. Unfortunately his granddaughter was in the seat directly behind me and kicked her way from coast to coast. Cullum himself was much better mannered.
Posted by SWoodyWhite @ 03/18/2002 02:09 AM PST
Any guess on the value of a singed Dean Cornwell called "Conqueror of Yellow Fever"?
Posted by Deborah @ 10/12/2003 03:01 PM PST
Any guess on the value of a signed Dean Cornwell called "Conqueror of Yellow Fever"?
Posted by Deborah @ 10/12/2003 03:02 PM PST
Any guess on the value of a signed Dean Cornwell called "Conqueror of Yellow Fever"?
Posted by Deborah @ 10/12/2003 03:02 PM PST
Any guess on the value of a signed Dean Cornwell called "Conqueror of Yellow Fever"?
Posted by Deborah @ 10/12/2003 03:02 PM PST