Replies: 16 Unseemly Comments
Bruce, thanks for the clarification on the macaroni and cheese. As for the Liza story taking the cake, I'm afraid someone left the cake out in the rain. As for Bock and Harnick, almost the complete score to "Tenderloin" (especially "Little Old New York").
"Mister Wonderful" and "Too Close For Comfort" (almost anybody's version, and there are aplenty) are great. "Tonight at Eight" would have to round out this particular list. You want any more Johnny Mercer songs? I'm still thinking of them!
Posted by Kerry @ 03/22/2002 09:02 AM PST
I hope that this unseemly event doesn't change Liza and David's plans to adopt four children of different races in the near future (as they confided in a magazine interview recently). Everybody knows that only tacky Midwesterners acquire their offspring as a matched set; the In Thing is to pick them up piece-by-quirky-piece. Although heaven only knows why L & D didn't just list "children" when they were registering for their other "must-haves" before the wedding. Now they'll have to purchase the little darlings themselves!
I'm signing the kids to a contract ASAP giving me the rights to their future "Mommie and Daddie Dearest" tell-alls.
Posted by Lulu @ 03/22/2002 09:23 AM PST
Didn't you ask for favorite Bock & Harnick songs, means ones they composed together. Harnick wasn't involved in Mr. Wonderful, only Bock, so if you meant joint compositions, Too Close For Comfort and Mr. Wonderful are out.
Posted by steveg @ 03/22/2002 09:33 AM PST
Hmmm.... Liza, publicity, is it me or do those two words go hand in hand?
My best friend and I were joking about Liza's wedding how we weren't invited seeing how everybody else in the free world was. And now, we have to feel Liza's pain and how those 'three black kids' felt 'no joy' by not getting her diamond crucifix... like she's a practicing Catholic, anyway. I must say, though, it was quick thinking by the chauffer to close the window!! :-)
I just hope Liza's recovered from her ordeal and will find peace and comfort in her new, happy marriage. As David Gest said, "I know who I am, Liza knows who she is. We'll die in each other's arms" (as said to Larry King).
Long live Bruce!!!
Posted by Paul @ 03/22/2002 09:38 AM PST
actually, Bruce, the Broadway Radio Show for this Sunday will be our encore presentation of the very first show we did with Susan Egan as we play songs from her brand new CD "So Far"
the following Sunday we will return with a whole new show with writer/director Mark Savage as we listen to songs from the new cast recording of "Pinafore!"
Posted by Donald @ 03/22/2002 10:13 AM PST
If we can have Bock without Harnick we can certainly have Harnick without Bock. I love Harnick's revue songs "When The Sea Is All Around Us," "Merry Little Minuet," "The Shape of Things" and the complete "Medea in Disneyland." Almost everything B&H did together deserves mention, especially all of She Loves Me! But they weren't exactly slumming with The Apple Tree, Fiorello, Tenderloin, Fiddler on the Roof, The Rothschilds, Man on the Moon, etc.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 03/22/2002 10:41 AM PST
Alright, I apologize for the B without H songs. It's all Johnny Mercer's fault!
Posted by Kerry @ 03/22/2002 10:57 AM PST
Favorite B&H -- the aching romanticism of "Will He Like Me?", and the loving humor of "Do You Love Me?" And both question-songs to boot.
Posted by Phil Crosby @ 03/22/2002 11:17 AM PST
"Garbage" is another great Harnick revue song (which I'm currently arranging for Portland's superb Susannah Mars, so it's stuck in the ol' brain). I am particularly partial to "The Rothschilds"; I feel it's an unfairly neglected score with some real gems, including "Sons" (as Daddy to two myself, it's particularly meaningful to me) and "He Tossed a Coin." Has this show ever been revived? And if not, why not?
Posted by JMK @ 03/22/2002 11:31 AM PST
I adore the picture of Liza's wedding party, featuring her two bridesmaids, Liz Taylor and Mary Tyler Moore. Wait - isn't that Mary with that parted in the middle 60's 'do, Peter Pan collar, junky jewelry, and surgically stretched face? MICHAEL JACKSON?
I've been lucky enough to do THE APPLE TREE and SHE LOVES ME, and I love both of them above and beyond FIDDLER, which, to me, is trying a little too hard. The wistfulness of the Overture of SHE LOVES ME, leading directly into "Good Morning, Good Day" is the sweetest Bock and Harnick sequence I know.
Posted by BobG @ 03/22/2002 11:53 AM PST
I can't believe no one's mentioned "When Did I Fall in Love" from FIORELLO! God, I love that song....
I also love "Gorgeous" from The Apple Tree (I know, it's silly, but I love it!), and "Tonight At Eight" from She Loves Me...
Posted by Anita @ 03/22/2002 02:25 PM PST
Penny by Penny from their version of A Christmas Carol is a very sweet song. When did I fall in love -- especially sung by Audra McDonald. I concur with the entire show She Loves Me as well. How about In My Own Lifetime from the Rothchilds, or Little Tin Box from Fiorello and Far from the home I love from Fiddler...
Posted by Craig @ 03/22/2002 08:42 PM PST
I love Fiddler, especially Now I Have Everything. I think Fiddler is pretty much perfect. I also love Will He Like Me? and She Loves Me.
Posted by Lolita @ 03/22/2002 09:43 PM PST
It's late enough that probably not many will read this, but I'll still weigh in with my vote.
First that comes to mind is "Chavaleh" from Fiddler. Also from Fiddler, "L'Chaim" and "Tevye's Dream"...just great fun to sing those. I've always loved belting out "you must have heard wrong, Grandma...". "Eve," "It's a Fish," and the title song from The Apple Tree, as well as "Tonight at Eight" from She Loves Me. I am shamefully lacking in knowledge of Fiorello and their other scores, so this list is the best I can do.
Posted by Jed @ 03/23/2002 02:43 AM PST
As usual, an impossible task, when you have a team that manages gorgeous ballads, hilarious comedy songs, perfect musical scenes--everything, in fact, that makes life worth living.
Can't you ask us a bout, say Llord Lloyd Weber? Then, without Tim Rice, we would have only a handful to choose from.
Herewith, off the top of my head:
"My Gentle Young Johnny", pure, beautiful longing.
"Artificial Flowers", and a tip of the Hatlo hat to Bobby Darin
"The Picture of Happiness", the perfect antithesis of "Artificial Flowers".
"Dear Friend"--both of them. I think the one from TENDERLOIN is a musical gem. Who else has written two totally different songs with the same title?
"Little Old New York", so much grittier than all the other I-Heart-NY songs.
"You Are Not Real" When I first heard Alan Alda sing that, I had just graduated from Caltech, taking physics with Richard Feynman. Little did I know that Alda would eventually play my physics professor on stage.
"Oh to Be a Movie Star" Sometimes Totally Cute actually works.
"The Bum Won" and
"Politics and Poker" capture the flavor of the era so perfectly, plus "A Little Tin Box".
"Marie's Law" in the original, uncensored version, which I find offensive but unfortunately very authentic to the era.
For further offensiveness, let's restore "Tango Tragique" to productions of SHE LOVES ME.
"Go to Sleep, Whatever You Are", for what it says about parenting.
"She Loves Me" for lyrical whimsy.
And everyone must visit my friend Frank Kelly's Bock & Harnick Web Page:
http://www.geocities.com/Broadway/Orchestra/4626/Bock_and_Harnick.html
Bill
Posted by William F. Orr @ 03/23/2002 08:41 AM PST
CORRECTION:
Although I still want to include "Marie's Law", my comment on offensiveness clearly relates to the wife-beating in "The Very Next Man". Senility strikes again.
And how could we all leave out "Unfair"? Or anything else they've written, for that matter.
Posted by William F. Orr @ 03/23/2002 09:00 AM PST