Replies: 11 Unseemly Comments
"Old Devil Moon," hands down. What a simply gorgeous melody.
Posted by Phil Crosby @ 04/01/2002 10:55 AM PST
I agree with Phil - "Old Devil Moon" is MY favorite, too! "What did I Have That I Don't Have" is perhaps my second favorite....
Posted by Anita @ 04/01/2002 11:13 AM PST
Someone in April
One More Walk Around The Garden
Old Devil Moon
How Could You Believe Me
Look To The Rainbow
Who Is There Among Us Who Knows - (just because it's relatively unknown)
You're All The World To Me
This is usually my pre-breakfast exercise - ie checking out who wrote what for this column. Hope you don't run out of suggestions BK. I need the exercise and enjoy reading the thoughts of your other readers.
I suspect I am one of the few people left on earth who have not seen ET. Maybe I should catch up with AI as well this year. Next up will be "Gosford Park" I hope. Have you seen the DVD of "Putting It Together" yet? (Or did I miss your "review"?)
Posted by Tom Guest (from OZ) @ 04/01/2002 01:58 PM PST
When the Idle Poor Become the Idle Rich, and all of Finian's Rainbow. It's really too bad the revival never got off of the ground. I got to see it in Cleveland, and it really was quite good. If they ever try to do it again, they should keep the original book, though.
Posted by Hapgood @ 04/01/2002 02:42 PM PST
I think that everything from On a Clear Day You Can See Forever is my whole list.
Bruce- Today's Hinky (Or Hunky as I like to call him) Meltz and Ernest Ernest song was my favorite.
Posted by Lolita @ 04/01/2002 03:43 PM PST
Well, you won't believe it - I found another Hinky Meltz and Ernest Ernest song which has something to do with today's notes. That's two in one day - a record. This one is called The Merry Pranksters. It's very Danny Kaye, and I only wish he could have song it.
THE MERRY PRANKSTERS Music by Hinky Meltz Lyrics by Ernest Ernest
The merry pranksters,
The merry pranksters,
They play their pranks
And then they run
They play their pranks
And have such fun
They're merry merry
Quite contrary
Pranksters.
The merry pranksters,
The merry pranksters.
Their pranks they play
With mirth and glee
Their pranks they play
With frequency
They're merry merry
Solitary pranksters.
They do not tarry
For they're merry
Quite contrary pranksters.
They do their pranks
They do them well
And where they'll strike
No one can tell
They're here, they're there
And then they're not
They play their pretty pranks
A lot -
They flit about, they prank and run,
And when all of their pranking's
done,
You think they're through
But they are not
For there's one prank that
They forgot
The merry merry
Au contraire-y
Slightly mad so do be
Wary
Very very
Merry merry
Pranksters.
Such a nice song for this very very merry merry April Fool's Day.
Posted by bk @ 04/01/2002 03:59 PM PST
No one has yet mentioned:
"How Could You Believe Me When I Said I Love You When You Know I've Been A Liar All My Life", which he wrote with Alan J. Lerner during a 12-minute taxi ride.
Also, "If I'm Not Near the One I Love" along with "Old Devil Moon" from FINIAN'S RAINBOW.
I agree with Bruce on "She Wasn't You", "On a Clear Day", and "Hurry, It's Lovely Up Here"; but what about "Melinda"?
And my very favorite from ON A CLEAR DAY, "What Did I Have that I Don't Have?" Top preformance by Edie Gorme--with Emily Skinner running a close second. I hate what Streisand did to the rhythm in the movie. But then the movie redeemed itself with the visuals to "Come Back to Me".
Quoted around here? "On the S. S. Bernard Cohen", "On a Clear Day", "When the Idle Poor...".
Posted by William F. Orr @ 04/01/2002 05:18 PM PST
In no particular order: "Come Back To Me," "You're All the World to Me" (Blossom Dearie had a great version-- second to Mr. Astaire's), "If This Isn't Love" and "How Are Things in Glocca Morra?" "The Lady's in Love With You" (Nellie Lutcher had a terrific version), "Too Late Now" (almost anybody's version, although Cleo Laine has a wonderful recording of this), and, of course, "What Did I Have..."
"(I've Got) The Sunday Jumps" is another great one. Oh, and "Open Your Eyes" is quite lovely.
Posted by Kerry @ 04/01/2002 05:54 PM PST
Update on the Sony reissue of the 1956 original Broadway cast recording of Li?l Abner . As it turns out, the recording was not made in stereo, but rather in the ?binaural? process, with the singers and instrumentalists in separate channels. So it appears that the recording will be issued in mono, except for two orchestral tracks, the overture and the newly-discovered ?Sadie Hawkins Day Ballet.?
But the good news is that the original tapes have yielded more previously unreleased material: "What's Good for General Bullmoose" and a reprise of "Jubilation T. Cornpone" will join the already announced bonuses (?Sadie Hawkins Day?; ?There?s Room Enough for Us? from the film soundtrack; Rosemary Clooney in two songs, one a cut number; and Percy Faith?s orchestra in another cut song).
from Ken Mandelbaum
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 04/02/2002 02:44 AM PST
Ah, Finian's Rainbow... one of the most amazing scores in the canon, IMHO. I have to put in a vote for "When I'm not Near the Girl I Love" (forced rhymes or not, it's more fun than anything written in the last 20 years).
Posted by Elan @ 04/02/2002 05:09 AM PST
Burton Lane was easily one of the most undervalued composers in the musical theatre. Finian's Rainbow and On A Clear Day are, as already stated below, great scores. Of all the songs NOT listed here, my favorite would have to be "How About You," set to that great Ralph Freed lyric "I like New York in June, how about you?" One of the five best New York songs ever written.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 04/02/2002 07:03 AM PST