Replies: 15 Unseemly Comments
Hello, one and all. Good Sunday. I am sitting here in wet hair and a bathrobe and I should be getting glamorously dressed for church. But I am NOT, I am reading the addendum. My answer to yesterdays question is:
Annie Get Your Gun. I saw the show and loved it, but the cd bored me to tears. (This is the Bernadette version.)
Posted by Lolita @ 04/28/2002 06:08 AM PST
My trivia question for the week:
What do the musicals Street Scene, She Loves Me and Anne of Green Gables have in common?
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 04/28/2002 08:32 AM PST
Were are you, One and All?
I have a general question for everyone. I've long been a fan of the movie Carousel. But I do not have a cd of the show... Every time I look in the store, there are so many that I don't know which one to choose. So, if anyone can point me in the right direction, I would be eternally grateful.
Thanks ever so, and START POSTING!!!
Posted by Lolita @ 04/28/2002 01:37 PM PST
I was so busy yesterday that all my computer time was devoted to making a traditional X-rated birthday card for my Joe, who is 47 today.
So I did manage to read BK's notes for Saturday. And this morning I read BK's notes for Sunday. How do you spell déja vu? Or, more precisely, déja lu?
Well, I am looking forward, as are we all, to hearing all about the benefit tomorrow. But as for now, my Birthday Boy is calling. And this is one day when, "What do you think it is, your birthday?" won't work.
Posted by William F. Orr @ 04/28/2002 02:40 PM PST
Lolita--if you're looking for the soundtrack to the movie, there have only been two CD releases. Get the more recent, remastered and filled-with-extra-tracks version. Both the original Broadway cast (which has some technical imperfections due to its age) and the recent Broadway revival have their good points.
Re: Sweet Smell. Well, I think maybe I like Hamlisch's music more than BK, but I have to say, Carnelia's lyrics just drive me up a wall on several occasions, especially when he repeats his "rhyming" words in the same sentence: "combing with my comb," "smell the smell of success," "blow by blow by blow by blow". I mean, come on--isn't the show lyric supposed to a model of craft, not repetition?
Posted by JMK @ 04/28/2002 02:40 PM PST
Another good Carousel is the Studio with Barbara Cook, Sarah Brightman I believe it is song complete with the exception of the Beach Ballet and the June Dance. These can be found on the expanded Soundtrack previously mentioned. There is also the reimagined Londonon Revival which I believe has the complete version of the ballet. It has most of the songs but is not sung as well as the original Broadway cast, the film or the MCA Studio with Barbara Cook.
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 04/28/2002 03:41 PM PST
Sorta outside the realm of this group of ours. But I was CD shopping and I came across a CDs of this young singer from Europe named Michael Junior. His first cd the cover photo he is blond as blond can be (1999) and the most recent cd cover (2001) His hair (and eybrows) are a dark brunette. Can someone's hair change so drastically? He's a kid! Did he dye it? Anyone hazzard a guess?
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 04/28/2002 03:44 PM PST
There are many good recordings of Carousel, but if you only buy one you should have John Raitt's definitive performance as Billy Bigelow. The original Decca album is not nearly as good as the RCA Lincoln Center production (with Jerry Orbach as Jigger). Sarah Brightman on the Barbara Cook version is a terrific Carrie, but Cook sounds too mature for Julie (a role she had played several decades earlier at City Center). Ramey is too stiff and to bass for Billy. The London and Broadway revivals are both good but great singing is not their primary feature. The revised soundtrack is actually pretty darn good, but Raitt is still the best Billy.
And as for Annie Get Your Gun, the recent revival massacred the score. Stick with Merman, Kim Criswell or Judy Kaye -- they're all great Annies.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 04/28/2002 04:28 PM PST
As for BK's question of the day, I was very confused by the original Capitol cast album of Follies, thought it made no sense at all. Until, of course, I saw the show. I still think it's the best Broadway production I have ever seen (this is the ORIGINAL version I'm talking about). Conversely, Merrily Roll Along has a brilliant cast album, but the original production was a mess (I'm sure later productions were much better). I feel the same way about The Goodbye Girl -- love the album, disliked the production.
Posted by Robert Armin @ 04/28/2002 04:36 PM PST
The Annie Get Your Guns
The Lincoln Center Version with Merman. The original Broadway version is an awful representation of the score.Merman still has the pipes.
Kim Criswell/John McGlinn is the complete representation of the score as it fist opened on Broadway. Songs and dance material. No extra material.
The Judy Kaye/John Yap version is the Lincoln Center revision of the score on 2 cds. It has additional material like musical underscoring and additional music not found on the Kim Criswell.
I think all three are great.
PS The soundtrack version has the Betty Hutton and the Judy Garland versions. Several songs were dropped and other songs had their lyrics "cleaned" up. Interesting to see two very different people perform the role. I have the DVD release. I think Betty Hutton is a little too broad in her portrayl and the footage with Garland despite looking tired she was great I think I would have prefered her.
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 04/28/2002 05:08 PM PST
I am still a little confused about the trivia question. This is the part I am a little foggy about
the up-and-coming choreographer/director cast member, (OK understand this) who the up-and-coming choreographer/director cast member worked with several times (Don't understand this)
Anyone can clarify?
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 04/28/2002 05:12 PM PST
First off, for the lady who loves the "movie" of "Carousel." There is one choice: It's the remastered, expanded edition released last year (or in 2000) by Angel (27352). This CD offers all the music in the film, including Louise's "Ballet." As a bonus -- and it truly IS a bonus -- we get for the FIRST TIME EVER the complete "Carousel Waltz" that started the mono and stereo LPs of the soundtrack. The difference is that the mono version was complete, but the Stereo version never was. NOW IT IS. Incidentally, it is this extended waltz that was recorded especially for the soundtrack release. It was never part of the film and never intended as an Overture for use in theatrical presentations. Angel also release expanded versions of "Oklahoma!" (brilliant recording) and "The King and I" (I have the expanded, Nick Redman-produced CD that came with the 40th Anniversary Boxed LD. I'm told that Angel used that as a master, so I didn't buy the Angel version).
Second, "Annie Get Your Gun" -- how amazing that Rhino unearthed virtually complete stereo tracks of the Garland recordings while all the Hutton "actual" recordings are in a muddied mono. This is the most disappointing musical recording I've gotten from them. And yes, the Garland versions are much better and more fun than the Hutton ones.
Michael -- I wish I could clarify BK's trivia question. But that road leads to oblivion....!
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 04/28/2002 06:02 PM PST
Michael, I emailed Bruce about this very thing last night. I believe I have correctly identified the show, movie stars, dead co-star (hmmmm....), and director/choreographer in the cast, but that guy's connections are numerous (kind of like BK's!), and I personally am unclear as to what BK meant by "created" an enormously successful musical--are we talking book, music/lyrics, or, in the case of a star vehicle, the star, or in the case of a star producer, the producer? All of these connections exist with the director/choreographer I think BK has in mind.
Posted by JMK @ 04/28/2002 06:06 PM PST
I saw Merrily We Roll Along twice on Broaday in previews--just like I did with Sweeney Todd--the changes between the two perfomances were erormous, and it was clearly a mess. And I had wanted to like it so!
Well, I may have been partly blinded by the sets and costumes and the things Prince kept throwing in haphazardly, like the pop art beanbag chairs in the sixties scene with Charlie coming back from Vietnam. You kept wondering what the show was supposed to be about.
Franklin Shepherd's nervous breakdown during the commencement speech was particularly annoying.
Anyway, when the cast album came out, I knew immediately that this was one of my favorite Sondheim scores. I hadn't really noticed the score in the theatre because the music and the production seemed to be doing different shows.
Later, my University did a production which I absolutely loved! This despite the fact that the show had been postponed for two weeks--I mentioned this in a letter to Bruce's close personal friend Stephen Sondheim, who gratiously informed me that they had intended to perform the show forwards in time, but he had threatened legal action.
I love every recording of the music, and I hope it doesn't live out the rest of its life as the Score in Search of a Book.
Posted by William F. Orr @ 04/28/2002 07:40 PM PST
Now I must assume that Bruce is going to be getting in late tonight, totally exhausted, music ringing in his ears, stuffed with cheese slices and ham chunks, without the strength for one more Pudding Dance in him.
And the last thing he will do before communing with his pillow is to clear his mind of all the excitement and worry of the day by reading our delightful and edifying posts.
So may I say: Bravo, Maestro! We love you, one and all! (Do I hear a "Hear! Hear!" out there?) Now get yourself some well-deserved rest.
Posted by William F. Orr @ 04/28/2002 07:50 PM PST