Replies: 39 Unseemly Comments
How delightful to read
responses by Mr. Guy Haines
here at his site. I'd say Ask GH
Day was a smashing
success, but success would
prefer I not say such things
until it's prior record of
smashing and other such
vandalism is cleared.
As to songs for GH to sing, I'll
come up with some answers
after some sleep.
Everyone go out and stock up
on ham chunks and cheese
slices, as we are in for grand
celebration tomorrow when we
have our 300th
notes!!! How disappointed I
am that I will most likely be
away from computers all of
Friday and therefore miss the
festivities!
Posted by Jed @ 08/29/2002 02:04 AM PST
Even though I didn't submit a question to the reclusive Mr. Haines, I do thank him for taking the time out of his day to answer our querys.
I would love to hear Guy tackle two of my favorite duets, both counterpoints, written by the wonderful Mr. Irving Berlin.
I Hear Singing and You're Just in Love from Call Me Madam sung with, perhaps, Judy Kaye.
Old Fashioned Wedding from Annie, Get Your Gun sung with Miss Reba McEntire.
Posted by Ben @ 08/29/2002 05:30 AM PST
Darnitall my questions did not get answered.... how sad I am that I have to wait until some unannounced yet Ask GH day occurs. Fiddlesticks I say! Incidently, Mr. Guy Haines was incorrect about that series of questions. I posted no such questions under a pseudonym (or a pseudolys for that matter). I asked questions under the very name I was given at birth by my parents. But I am EXTREMELY honored that Mr. GUY HAINES knows who I am...quite flattering really..
More later..
Posted by Craig @ 08/29/2002 05:30 AM PST
BK-
Tell us the make and model of the phone so we can all ooh and ahh :)
Posted by Craig @ 08/29/2002 07:54 AM PST
I'd like to hear Guy Haines do a duet with Bruce Kimmel of "Me and My Shadow".
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 08/29/2002 08:03 AM PST
Guy and Bruce doing "You're Nothing Without Me."
Posted by Jason @ 08/29/2002 08:20 AM PST
How about a Haines/Kimmel duet of "You're Nothing Without Me"?
Posted by Pam @ 08/29/2002 08:24 AM PST
Haines and Kimmel singing "Where Would I Be (Without You)" from "Roar of the Greasepaint, Smell of the Crowd"
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 08/29/2002 09:17 AM PST
Haines & Kimmel in a duet of Cole Porter's Friendship
Posted by Ben @ 08/29/2002 10:03 AM PST
Or, they could pull a Bing and Danny and do a parody on "Sisters"....as a tribute to Vera-Ellen and Rosemary Clooney!!!
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 08/29/2002 10:38 AM PST
Or how about Guy and BK together on "Bosom Buddies" from MAME?
Posted by Jay @ 08/29/2002 11:15 AM PST
Not a duet, but I think Guy Haines' vocal stylings would be perfectly suited to "Live Alone and Like It" from Dick Tracy.
Posted by Jed @ 08/29/2002 12:03 PM PST
Well, I did see the OBC of A Little Night Music, mere moments after it opened, and something kind of funny happened the matinee I saw it. Being a naive, country boy at the time on his first visit to NYC, I did not know (this is what I overheard from other patrons) that Ms. Johns evidently had a bit of a drinking habit which sometimes interfered with her onstage duties. I can't exactly remember what number, perhaps "A Weekend in the Country", but there were these magnificent birch trees on plexiglas plates that wheeled in from the side, and I noticed that Ms. Johns was strangely upstage and about to get whacked by the ones coming in from stage right, and was blithely ignorant of this fact. Mr. Cariou must have seen the same thing, because I remember as he was singing he virtually bounded upstage, calmly grabbed Ms. Johns by the shoulder, moved her downstage a bit, and returned to his position without missing a beat. I had no real idea of what had happened until the people next to me started gossiping about it.
Posted by JMK @ 08/29/2002 12:08 PM PST
I would like to hear Guy Haines sing "In Lily's Eyes" with Anthony Dale!
I'd also like to hear Guy singing on the following:
"Enough is Enough" with LaStreisand
"Till there was You" with Miss Babara Cook.
"Let's be Buddies" with Miss Elaine Stritch.
"With So Little to Be Sure of" with Miss Betty Buckley.
"I've Got a Crush on You" with Miss Linda Ronstadt.
"Old Devil Moon" with Miss Petula Clark.
"Unworthy of Your Love" with Miss Emily Skinner.
ANYTHING AT ALL with Miss Judy Kaye.
"There Once Was A Man" with Miss Doris Day, or should she prove unavailable, with Miss Susan Egan.
Posted by td @ 08/29/2002 12:09 PM PST
Sutton Foster -- Does anyone have the complete backstage story on this overnight sensation?
I think we all know that she was new to New York and was hired as understudy to another performer. Does anyone know "who" that performer is? What, exactly, were the difficulties with the first choice that led to them actually replacing her with the second choice?
This is the kind of stuff I like to read about. And what is that "other" performer doing now?
Somebody reading this Unseemly Message Board knows something!!
Spill!
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 08/29/2002 12:11 PM PST
Ron, I know the "who" but not the "why". The actress she replaced was Erin Dilley. The only time I've seen Ms. Dilley was in Encore's Babes In Arms and she was quite good and probably would have been as Milly (after Kristen Chenowith dropped out). The "who" has been mentioned many places, but I've never seen the "why".
While we are on the subject of replacements, Kristen Vigard in the title role and Maggie Task as Miss Hannigan were the actresses replaced by Andrea McArdle and Dorothy Louden in the original Annie, a story related often without the names.
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 08/29/2002 12:32 PM PST
By the way, ron, Ms. Foster was not "new" to New York. She was a chorus replacement in a couple of the long run Cameron Macintosh poperettas and I think she did a couple of other shows as well.
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 08/29/2002 12:34 PM PST
Duets for Guy Haines/BK to sing:
"Alone Together"
"My Own Best Friend"
"Together, Wherever We Go"
Songs for Guy alone:
"Don't Look At Me"
"If My Friends Could See Me Now"
"Why? Cause I'm A Guy" (From I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change)
Duet with Guy Stroman (from Forever Plaid):
"Sensitive New Age Guys"
Songs for someone else (BK?) to sing about Guy Haines:
"How Can You Describe A Face?"
"The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face"
Posted by Allan @ 08/29/2002 12:35 PM PST
Now, see, this IS the place to ask those important questions!
Thanks, William! I had been under the impression that "Millie" was Foster's first job, so I probably misheard something somewhere.
I've seen something on PBS about all the "Annie" travails...including the controversy over the original choice and McArdle's "last-minute" stepping up to the role. It has been a few years, so the particulars are pretty much gone, but someone involved in the production apparently championed McArdle all along and was happy when she was finally given the leading role. At least, that's what I got out of it.
(Someone straighten me out if I've got it wrong...or add to the continuing sage of unknown/unheard/seldom heard Broadway lore...I'm in THAT kind of mood today).
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 08/29/2002 12:50 PM PST
If you would like to see Ms. Dilly in a show, go see the Roundabout's revival of THE BOYS FROM SYRACUSE. She is currently starring as Luciana. I think she wouldn't have been a very good Millie. A Miss Dorothy, perhaps, but not Millie. And yes, Kristi Chenoweth was up for the role, too. That's why Marc Kudisch took the show (they were engaged at the time and he wanted to spend time with her).
There's the scoop.
Posted by Jason @ 08/29/2002 01:47 PM PST
Please thank Guy for all the answers. I made it easier for him by asking the same questions as everyone else. (Frankly, or Ralphly, I scrolled to the bottom, because I thought I should get a post in before it was too late. THEN I read the others.)
I would love to hear Guy and Jason Graae do a duet. I'll have to think of the song, though.
I think Guy could do a great job of "I Wish I Were In Love Again" (with either Emily Skinner or Sally Mayes). (Actually I think it'd be great with Guy and Jason, but I don't know how well that would play in Peoria.)
Guy by himself could do a nice job of "Fools Rush In" and "I Remember You"
More later
Posted by Kerry @ 08/29/2002 01:53 PM PST
If I spent a little more time on this I probably could have come up with a very special list
Guy Haines and Bruce Kimmel (An Ordinary Couple from The Sound of Music)
I Like Your Style (Guy Haines and Jason Graae from Barnum)
Two Lost Souls (Brent Barrett and Guy Haines from Damn Yankees)
Impossible (Guy Haines and John Raitt from A Funny Thing Happened...)
I Remember It Well (Dame Edna and Guy Haines from Gigi)
All For the Best (Guy Haines and Michael Rupert from Godspell)
Poems (Guy Haines and Ron Raines from Pacific Overtures)
Wait Till We're Sixty-five (Guy Haines and Tammi Tappen from On a Clear Day...)
Our Private World (Judy Kaye and Guy Haines from On the 20th Century)
But We Didn't (Guy Haines and Cindy Williams from Stages)
and
On the Atchinson, Topeka and the Santa Fe (Guy Haines and Bruno Antony from Harvey Girls)
Posted by Michael Shayne @ 08/29/2002 02:11 PM PST
I think the elusive Mr. Haines could do a very nice job on either "Soon It's Gonna Rain" or "They Were You" (or both).
Posted by Kerry @ 08/29/2002 02:58 PM PST
Whatever happened to Barbara Harris? Did she ever record a solo album of any kind? I followed her Broadway career and recordings quite avidly, and saw THE APPLE TREE about three times. I always wished she would have done more solo recordings.
Posted by Ross Care @ 08/29/2002 04:18 PM PST
Barbara Harris made a few films after APPLE TREE, most noteably Robert Altman's "NASHVILLE". I don't know what she's done since then. She was one of the first "I'm too big a star to do matinees" divas and was covered in APPLE TREE by Phyllis Newman who's still around and active.
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 08/29/2002 05:05 PM PST
First off, a big haineshisway.com welcome to Ross Care, a very nice fellow. We hope he'll enjoy himself here and become a regular Hainsie/Kimlet in short order.
I'm enjoying the ideas for Guy, both solo and duet songs. We may just have to do a second album together.
Posted by bk @ 08/29/2002 05:07 PM PST
Jason: Thanks!
For Kimmel/Haines: "I'm Past My Prime" : )
For Ross Care: WELCOME, old friend!
For Tom in Oz: THANK YOU! This CD is wonderful!!!!!
I'm looking forward to the next four days as I'm off tomorrow. Have plenty of stuff to do and listen to. I finally got around to ordering a VHS copy of "The Last of Sheila" -- it arrived yesterday. Can't wait to watch it. Haven't seen it since its first run in theaters (and even then, I think I saw a dirty print in a second-run theater in Indianpolis).
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 08/29/2002 06:18 PM PST
According to the beginning of these here notes, I have permission to be contrary. I feel downright liberated!
Posted by Kerry @ 08/29/2002 06:34 PM PST
Ron, since you remember The Last of Sheila from it's theatrical run, you probably already remember the outcome. However, if you don't, there was a particular moment in the tape when I didn't let der Brucer watch any more, unless he came up with some solution. The moment was when Richard Benjamin was strolling along the docks at night. By that moment, everything you need to know has been given you by Mssrs. Sondheim and Perkins.
I dearly wish this film was out on DVD, since searching for the clues would be so much easier with chapter stops. BTW, der Brucer really did figure out the mystery, with very little prompting from me (and I had the hardest time keeping a straight face as he was working his way through the clues, he was so excited and puppy-with-a-new-chew-toy-like).
Posted by S. Woody White @ 08/29/2002 06:39 PM PST
The earlier talk of Nashville brings to mind a song for Guy: the Oscar-winning "I'm Easy," which I'd do with a very simple guitar accompaniment.
In fact, start the new disc with Guy doing "I'm Easy" as a solo, then finish the set with Guy leading an entire chorus singing "It Don't Bother Me." It would give him a chance to work in all those soloists he's been dying to pair off with, but never has figured out how or when.
Posted by S. Woody White @ 08/29/2002 06:44 PM PST
More:
Brent Barrett and Guy doing "Wonderful Music" from "110 in the Shade."
"A Man and a Woman" (also from 110) Maybe with Judy Kaye
ANY duet with Liz Callaway
Something with Brad Kane ("Put On Your Sunday Clothes" perhaps)
"I'm Glad I'm Not Young Anymore" from "Gigi" (although Guy Haines is ageless, I think he could do this song well.)
Posted by Kerry @ 08/29/2002 07:09 PM PST
I'd like to hear Guy sing that lovely standard, "Time After Time." If I can sing it, and if Chris Montez can sing it, I know it's within Guy's range.
Also, maybe something of Tony Hatch's (unless that's done for the Tony Hatch album), something of Barry Manilow's, something of Rupert Holmes, and something of Bruce Kimmel's.
Posted by Kerry @ 08/29/2002 07:17 PM PST
How about gathering Guy Haines, Greg Jbarra, Jason Graae and Bruce Kimmel together for a downtown rendition of Frank Loesser's "Standing on the Corner?"
Posted by td @ 08/29/2002 07:32 PM PST
S. Woody: I DON'T recall the outcome. So thanks...I'll give myself a little challenge at that point in the movie!
: )
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 08/29/2002 07:59 PM PST
Thank you to Guy Haines for taking the time to answer our questions!
Posted by Laura @ 08/29/2002 09:05 PM PST
Yes, I'm sure it was a nice break for Bruce who got to relax finally.
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 08/29/2002 09:50 PM PST
Oh -- and welcome to Ross!!
Donna, is the September calendar ready yet?
And where is Dolores formerly Lolita?
Posted by Laura @ 08/29/2002 10:49 PM PST
I'm not so sure BK got to relax all that much. After all, he not only had to read the questions, afterwards he (or someone) had to transcribe Guy's answers. And, while Guy speaks and sings perfectly clearly when he has a microphone directly in front of him, at other times (such as at Bookfellows Bookstore, where I witnessed it myself) he has a habit of putting his hand in front of his mouth. That camera-shy thing of his, y'know. So some of what Guy was telling BK has to have come out a little mumbled. BK deserves a round of applause himself for the extra effort he put into making"Ask Guy Haines Day" such a success!
Posted by S. Woody White @ 08/29/2002 10:50 PM PST
So many great suggestions. I dug out my old Bobby Darin/Johnny Mercer album "Two Of A Kind". The title track seems apt as do many of the other songs.
Have a great weekend everyone.
Friday 5.00pm here.
Posted by Tom Guest (from OZ) @ 08/29/2002 11:58 PM PST