Replies: 55 Unseemly Comments
First post? We'll see...
Well, it's obvious, isn't it? Starring as Ms. Dolly Levi, we must have...
Matthew Broderick!
Posted by Dave @ 02/24/2003 09:11 AM PST
Of course, if this were a Disney made-for-TV version of HELLO DOLLY!, the big question would be, "Who would Victor Garber play?"
Posted by Dave @ 02/24/2003 09:27 AM PST
I HATE when it does that! Mr. Mark Bakalor will be along in a bit to fix it, I suppose.
Posted by bk @ 02/24/2003 09:31 AM PST
Worst cast Dolly? Why, Miss Carol Channing, of course!
Posted by Jay @ 02/24/2003 09:39 AM PST
The most obvious answer to who is wrong for Dolly is Carol Channing, but there is no chance she will be doing it again as the Nederlanders have announced that there will be an all new production when they produce it in 2005 as part of their Jerry “Why write a new show as long as they keep doing revivals and compilation revues” Herman Festival.
Actually almost every Dolly I think of could bring new qualities to the role. Remember in the 60s she was played by people as varied as Phyllis Diller, Eve Arden, Ethel Merman and Betty Grable and each of these women did an excellent job in a different way. Of current Broadway performers I would imagine that Lea Salonga, Marrissa Tomei or Molly Ringwald would be wrong, but every other name I thought of --- from Lea Delaria to Harvey Fierstein to Debbie Gravitte could actually bring a new approach to this classic warhorse.
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 02/24/2003 09:41 AM PST
Good morning.
Now, I know I'm a little weary this morning, but it wasn't fun thinking I was starting to get double vision - vertically - reading the first part of these notes. ;-) Ah, the joys of the internet and HTML!
As for casting Hello, Dolly... Meryl Streep? Madonna? Glenn Close? All of them "could" work, it would be just a matter of the whole performance and their take on it. I'll have to think a bit longer to come up with truly bad and inappropriate choices.
OH, but, of course, Michael Crawford would have to reprise his movie role. OR - Eureka! - HE could play Dolly!!!!
And it looks like I won't be able to make the chat tonight as I'll be in rehearsal... But I'm off next Sunday night!
Posted by Jose C. Simbulan @ 02/24/2003 09:54 AM PST
Dolly Levi: Christina Aguilera
Horace: Richard Chamberlain
Posted by Lulu @ 02/24/2003 09:56 AM PST
Bruce - did you watch the grammys? If so.. what did you think of the production?
As for Hello Dolly...
as Dolly: Ally Sheedy
as Horace: Andy Dick
Posted by Craig @ 02/24/2003 09:59 AM PST
I'll be back w/casting suggestions later but I had to laugh at Brockman fils suggestion of Andy Dick as Vandergelder. Made me smile.
My brand spanking new, handy dandy desktop computer arrived on Friday afternoon as I arrived home from work. Spent the entire weekend setting it up. So far, I'm happy though there are one or two minor problems and I have to get use to using Windows XP after Windows 98 but I'm a very happy camper right now. If I can be torn away from tweaking the machine this evening I will try to make it to chat.
Back later for Worst Cast Scenario starring ???
Posted by Ben @ 02/24/2003 10:05 AM PST
Am I the only one who has never heard any of the major Grammy nominated songs or albums and has never even heard of most of the people who have recorded them?
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 02/24/2003 10:05 AM PST
Hello, Dolly -- Bernadette Peters and David Cassidy.
Or, Donny and Marie Osmond.
Or, Michael Jackson, with Lea DeLaria as Horace Vandergelder!
I watched "June Moon" on DVD last night. I'm curious as to how much of the music in that show was written by Sondheim. The end credits were sung nicely, with Sondheim rating an "haitch" as "Sond - Heim" was sung out.
It had its moments. I thought it very intersting that one of the pieces Sondheim played at the piano as a "noodle" was "Che Gelida Manina" from "La Boheme."
Has no one among our New Yorkers yet seen "La Boheme" or have I missed their posts about it?
The DVD of the Australian production rarely leaves my player so enamored am I of it!
I've grown so accustomed to that cast that I can barely tolerate the OBC recording of the current production. The "lease" effective Rodolfo (IMO) -- Alfred Boe -- gets ALL the good arias of Rodolfo on the recording. His tenor is too florid for my tastes -- too much tremolo. Jesus Garcia's is best, but he gets piddly squat (the final act, which isn't a powerhouse for Rodolfo) on the recording. Just my opinion, though.
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 02/24/2003 10:21 AM PST
Worst casting Dolly: Roseanne
Posted by Laura @ 02/24/2003 10:34 AM PST
Dear Laura:
Roseanne would be worse than Michael Jackson?
LOL
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 02/24/2003 10:44 AM PST
At least Michael Jackson can sing. Remember Roseanne singing?
Posted by Laura @ 02/24/2003 10:49 AM PST
Actually, I can see it now. A major ABC special bringing back the cast of "Roseanne" in "Hello, Dolly!"
Dolly Levi -- Roseanne
Horace Vandergelder -- John Goodman
Cornelius Hackl -- Johnny Galecki
Irene Malloy -- Sara Gilbert
Barnaby Tucker -- Michael Fishman
Minnie Fay -- Lecy Goranson
Gussie Granger/Ernestina Simple -- Laurie Walters
Fritz -- Martin Mull
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 02/24/2003 10:54 AM PST
Actually...I think John Goodman would be fun as Horace.. am I crazy?
Posted by Craig @ 02/24/2003 10:58 AM PST
Someone asked the other day (I forgot who) about the upcoming reissue of the original cast album of Nine. Per today's Ken Mandelbaum column, the CD (to be released May 13) will be on 2 discs totalling 99 minutes. There will be 87 minutes of the original cast including longer versions of songs that have never been released in any format and Mandelbaum assumes it is the entire score. There will also be 12 minutes of demos by Maury Yeston. Check today's Broadway.Com for more details of this and the other four Sony Broadway reissues that will be released the same date.
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 02/24/2003 11:11 AM PST
Bruce, I think that Josh Groban beat Monica to the punch on "Cinema Paridiso" with lyrics. I might be mistaken though.
As for HELLO, DOLLY!:
Dolly - Judith Ivey
Horace - Gregory Harrison
Irene - Blythe Danner
Cornelius - Treat Williams
Minnie Fay - Britney Spears
Barnaby - Justin Timberlake
Ernestina - Harvey Fierstein
Posted by td @ 02/24/2003 11:25 AM PST
Pop-up windows! Ah! Some of us have been trying to encourage BK to switch from America Off-Line to Earthlink. Earthlink has a perfectly wonderful Pop-Up Blocker that smashes all those windows. It is very versitile, and you can over-ride it manually when you actually want to see a pop-up. There are lots of Pop-Up Blockers out there you can down-load, but I don't know which is best.
HELLO, DOLLY!
film remake, directed by Baz Luhrman
Dolly Levi - Nicole Kidman
Horace Vandergelder - Clint Eastwood ("I Talk to the Trees" is integrated into the new screenplay.)
Cornelius Hackl - Jim Carey
Irene Molloy - Jennifer Lopez
Barnaby Tucker - Pauly Shore
Minnie Fay - Callista Flockhart
Ermengarde Vandergeler - Gillian Anderson
Ambrose Kemper - John Leguizamo
Posted by William F. Orr @ 02/24/2003 11:31 AM PST
Oh a casting assignment. And what a terrific production it will be!
Dolly - Jenny Jones
Horace - Jerry Springer
Irene - Caroline Rhea
Cornelius - Wayne Brady
Barnaby - Jon Stewart
Minnie - Rotating cast of Barker's Beauties from The Price Is Right
Ermengarde - Kathy Griffin
Ambrose - Steve the Security Guard from Springer
AND they can just use the movie soundtrack!
Posted by Jrand52 @ 02/24/2003 11:39 AM PST
HELLO, DOLLY!
Broadway revival, directed by Baz Luhrman, with a new book by Baz Luhrman, base on his screenplay
Dolly Levi - Bernadette Peters
Horace Vandergelder - Luciano Pavarotti
Cornelius Hackl - Antonio Banderas
Irene Molloy - Joan Jette
Barnaby Tucker - Brent Barrett
Minnie Fay - Betty Buckley
Ermengarde Vandergeler - Rosie O'Donnell
Ambrose Kemper - Savion Glover
(Note: In the interest of appealling to a new generation, Mr. Lehrman has scrapped the songs by Mr. Herman and had a new score commissioned by Frank Wildhorn and Jim Steinman.)
Posted by William F. Orr @ 02/24/2003 11:49 AM PST
I've been meaning to ask this for a long time --
What does LOL stand for?
P.S. Monica Mancini puts me to sleep. No excitement to her singing IMHO.
Posted by Donna @ 02/24/2003 11:52 AM PST
William - and I hear that Baz has hired David Henry Hwang to rewrite the book...
Posted by Craig @ 02/24/2003 11:59 AM PST
Primarily, in internet lingo, LOL stands for "laughing out loud."
However, back in South Carolina, I have relatives who end their e-mails with LOL and mean "Lots of love..."
So...one must be careful!
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 02/24/2003 12:00 PM PST
Donna-
LOL = Laughing Out Loud
ROFL = Rolling on the Floor Laughing
LMAO = Laughing My Ass Off
ROFLMAO = Rolling on the Floor Laughing My Ass off
Posted by Craig @ 02/24/2003 12:00 PM PST
A question for Jose and Bruce..
If there should be a strike of the 802 - will the actors that appear on stage who are members of the union (a few shows have members of the cast play an instrument and subsequently are members of the union) be considered "scabs" ?
Just curious...
Posted by Craig @ 02/24/2003 12:05 PM PST
Thanks guys!
Posted by Donna @ 02/24/2003 12:05 PM PST
Bagdad! Don't underestimate Bagdad, a city rich in romantic oriental lore. Bagdad! You must investigate Bagdad, and learn a few of the facts you never knew before. Due west of the Garden of Eden, due east of the Gulf of Aiden, where every male and maiden is laden down with the blisses of Bagdad, this irresistible town.
Posted by Sadam Hussein @ 02/24/2003 12:08 PM PST
Him you let post?
Posted by Robert Armin @ 02/24/2003 12:15 PM PST
Oh my goodness! We've been overrun by interlopers!
I must be getting paranoid. Maybe it's contagious. ;-)
Posted by Dave @ 02/24/2003 12:29 PM PST
Well, I'm from Big D. Can't ya guess by the way I drawl and the way I dress?
Posted by George W. Bush @ 02/24/2003 12:39 PM PST
The problem with bad casting is that it may well be a success.
I shall of course be loyal to my misguided country:
Dolly: Dame Edna
Horace: Sir Les Patterson
Cornelius: Hugo Weaving
Barbaby: Hugh Jackman
Irene: Nicole Kidman
Minnie Fay: Dame Joan Sutherland
Ernestina: John Howard
Posted by Tom from Oz @ 02/24/2003 01:00 PM PST
Tom I think Barbaby is in a different play....but the perfect OZ casting for the part is Jason Donovan.
Posted by Jrand52 @ 02/24/2003 01:14 PM PST
BK - you can try the Pop Up Stopper that can be downloaded for free at
www.panicware.com
You try it for 30 days and then can purchase it if you like it. I have found it to be very effective.
Posted by Internet Junkie @ 02/24/2003 01:24 PM PST
Yep, I think Barbaby is from that find show "Song of the Souse."
Man! You just don't see revivals of that show any more.
Posted by Ron Pulliam @ 02/24/2003 01:34 PM PST
Dolly-Tiny Tim
Horace-Pee Wee Herman
Posted by Arnold M. Brockman @ 02/24/2003 01:55 PM PST
BK: As for the pop-up problem, I had something similar, and it actually turned out to be a type of "virus". It didn't do any harm to my system, but it was a little program that prompted the ad to pop up every now and then. You may want to do a scan - I use McAfee and it's caught and cleaned them before.
And as for AOL pop-ups - I've never really had a problem with them - even before they gave you the option of turning off/on their internal ads. External ads are a different story. Of course, AOL has those ads at Sign On and Sign Off, but that's been about it for me.
As for the union mess in New York... It will all depend which contract they are under. If an actor plays an instrument in a show, then he/she is more likely under AEA than AFM jurisdiction. As for on stage bands, then they would most likely come under the AFM.
Posted by Jose C. Simbulan @ 02/24/2003 02:09 PM PST
I shall have to miss yet another chat as I will be doing the Cabaret thing.
BK, I too have loved "Soldier in the Rain" ever since my Dad brought home a Mancini Greatest Hits LP (does anyone still wear an LP?) when I was maybe 8 and gave it to me.
And finally, in an alternate "Cinema Paradiso" universe, I am attempting to decipher the very strange and extremely gifted William Bolcom's manuscript for "Casino Paradise." Has anyone here ever dealt with a handwritten Bolcom score before? I'm redoing it for some people in legible printed software, but it is a challenge, let me tell you.
Posted by JMK @ 02/24/2003 02:37 PM PST
I love Paris!
Posted by Jacques Chirac @ 02/24/2003 03:05 PM PST
"What Annie! did for orphans, what The Music Man did for librarians, what The Sound of Music did for nuns, the new Broadway musical Frog and Toad is about to do for amphibians."
I heard that ad on the radio yesterday. Anyone know anything about this show?
Posted by William F. Orr @ 02/24/2003 03:12 PM PST
Chat is coming up in two hours - be there or be square or round.
Posted by bk @ 02/24/2003 03:58 PM PST
Ah! Don't you just love hyperbole? I am reminded of a review by Clive Barnes in the New York Times (yes, he was still at The Times, so that tells you long ago it was) of a show the name of which I cannot remember. The entirety of the review read something along the lines of the following:
"The producers of [name of show] promised that I would smile, smile, smile. I didn't, I didn't, I didn't."
Posted by Jay @ 02/24/2003 04:00 PM PST
Gary, Indiana
Gary, Indiana
Gary, Indiana
Let me say it once again.
Gary, Indiana
Gary, Indiana
Gary, Indiana
That's the town that knew me when.
Posted by Harold Hill @ 02/24/2003 04:30 PM PST
What in tarnation happened??? Naturally, Mr. Mark Bakalor isn't around to check it out. Did someone do something with italics or some weird code? Can someone undo what they've done?
Posted by bk @ 02/24/2003 04:49 PM PST
Looks okay to me....hmmm...Mr. BK you may have a virus.
Posted by Jrand52 @ 02/24/2003 04:51 PM PST
Now it's fine. Did anyone else have the weirdness I saw - no formatting or graphics, just type? I tried it several different ways, including Internet Explorer. Hmmm. Chat in one hour.
Posted by bk @ 02/24/2003 04:53 PM PST
Sometimes things happen on the WWW that defy explanation. Today on a message board, I got pages and pages of squares instead of letters. Eventually, it went away.
Gale Sondergaard was married to Abner Biberman, thus giving her a rather un-exotic last name.
Gale Biberman.
Abner Biberman - son of a wealthy dress manufacturer - was a member of the Group Theatre, co-starred with Frances Farmer in South of Pago Pago AND directed dear reader Susan Gordon in an episode of BEN CASEY.
Posted by Norman Einstein @ 02/24/2003 05:02 PM PST
Hear ye, hear ye, chat is now open.
Posted by bk @ 02/24/2003 05:52 PM PST
That chat was the grinchiest!
Posted by Dr. Seuss @ 02/24/2003 07:36 PM PST
What a lively and sparkling chat we had. And it is still going on even now. Why, soon we will be the most popular site on all the internet. I suggested if he were still alive that Sebastion Cabot would make a fine Dolly.
Posted by bk @ 02/24/2003 08:13 PM PST
My way to kill pop-ups is to use Mozilla as my browser. http://www.mozilla.org/releases/#1.2.1
Posted by Kit Lo @ 02/24/2003 09:02 PM PST
The Chat That Won't Die!!!
Lively and sparkling it was
indeed; both when it was
down to just me and Laura,
and then when the joint
resumed jumping with the
late-night crowd!
Posted by Jed @ 02/24/2003 10:31 PM PST
Well, here it is at 7:45am on Tuesday. I missed the chat because I was chatting with folks from Gateway and Iomega trying to get a piece of equipment to work. I consider myself to be quite computer literate and can set up a computer and assorted peripherals without assistance but when necessary information is not included, and the wrong software is sent with the hardware, what are you supposed to do??? Not only was I chatting with folks from Iomega, I had to go to their Web site (twice) to download the most current software (twice because the first tech assistant I spoke to "forgot" to tell me that I needed two separate programs). Well, that's all water under the bridge (it was beginning to resemble a bridge over troubled water -Simon and Garfunkle) because my computer is now up and running smoothly. Everything works, I have restored all files I wanted from my old computer. My ISP works fine and I won't be unceremoniously bumped off any longer. I stil have tweaking to do but I may actually come to chat next Sunday and stay for more than 15 minutes. Hooray!
Posted by Ben @ 02/25/2003 04:46 AM PST
A YEAR WITH FROG AND TOAD is a Children's show that is moving to Broadway in the hopes of appealing to a family audience. It totally sold out its initial engagement, but it remains to be seen if there is an audience for it at Broadway prices.
Posted by William E. Lurie @ 02/25/2003 06:03 AM PST
Well, in another hour and a half, I'll be setting out for Orlando! We're getting away for a few days at a nice resort and (naturally) doing Disney.
So I probably won't be around 'til Sunday or Monday. Hope you all have a nice week! :)
Posted by Lulu @ 02/25/2003 07:23 AM PST