TOD: This is difficult, as DtM says. I love most every note of Cy Coleman's. Even did a paper on him in college. And then rewrote it for another class.
The whole score for On the 20th Century, especially the overture
Witchcraft
When in Rome
The Best is Yet to Come
Hey, Look Me Over
On the Other Side of the Tracks
The Truth
Big Spender
Rhythm of Life
Where Am I Going?
My Personal Property
The Late, Great State of New York
Welcome to Holiday Inn
Ride Out the Storm
Spanglish
It's Not Where You Start
Join the Circus
The Colors of My Life
Hey There, Good Times
Someone Wonderful I Missed
Lovers on Christmas Eve
My Body
Too Old for the Oldest Profession
It's too early to remember any more, like the songs on "Unsung Broadway" from that divorce court musical.