As for tonight's IDOL: an off-night, I thought. No one did exceptional work, but two people did solid professional jobs: Blake and Melinda. Blake was the best he's ever been, and Melinda was her usual smooth, professional, elegant self.
Everyone else had problems of one kind of another. LaKisha had breathing problems and let the backup singers cover for her - not cool. Haley did that as well but with less secure vocals than LaKisha. Poor Phil's voice had a horrible crack near the end, and CHris's was a very "pitchy" performance, something he didn't get nailed for as he should have been.
Jordin's vibrato seemed erratic and her pitch verged on the sharp in her upper register, and Sanjaya, well, it was a touch better than most everything he's sung, but there's still nothing much there.
I think maybe Phil may go home this week and Haley saved due to her hot pants. Chris Richardson may also be in trouble.
For the first time in the competition, I voted tonight. About 1/3 of the time for Melinda and 2/3 of the time for Blake.