Re: IDOL and DR RonP's comments.
I think next weeks depends on what the judges say about the performances. If they really praise any singer, I think that singer will stay.
RE: Elliot. When you say he's the best talent on the show, are you going purely by voice? Because a)to me a popstar has to have that IT factor as well, and b)most of the people watching cannot tell if someone is singing a wrong note or completely on pitch.
I think the winner should have the whole package. And right now to me it seems like taylor has it in the bag. I actually liked him during the auditions a lot more. But he seems to be immensely popular.
I'm with Simon on Taylor -- every time he goes into his "schtick" his performance comes off as some hideous joke. He's wriggly dancing is appalling, actually. I know folks "enjoy" the package now...but frankly, Taylor does not seem capable of singing a song without squatting several times and squeezing his thighs together to compress his gonads. Last night's reprise of "Jailhouse Rock" was embarrassing to watch, frankly...and I suspect folks were enjoying it for the (IMO) wrong reason. They like it when folks make fools of themselves, apparently.
Katherine usually hits some atrocious notes that nearly put me into a seizure. Simon calls it "shrieky"...and that's how it seems to me, too.
I'm sorry DR Jennifer feels that "most of the people watching cannot tell if someone is singing a wrong note or completely on pitch." That's truly a shame, especially considering the fact that most people who vote on these shows do not follow up by supporting the singers when they put out albums.
I think auditions for the show are proof we live on a continent full of tone-deaf, clueless and ridiculously "Slow" individuals who delude themselves into thinking they, too, can be great singers.
I'm not sure what "whole package" DR Jennifer feels Taylor or Katherine possess that Elliott does not....but consistency, quality vocals and on-pitch delivery are not their best traits -- and it is, after all, about the singing.
I'd like to know why Jennifer thinks Elliott lakes "IT". I think Elliott has "IT" way over the rest. Apparently, quite a few others do, as well.
He has just as much stage presence and personality as anyone else on the show. Add to that his vocal talent, natural charm and gracious demeanor and he's head-and-shoulders above the pack, IMO.
Check this out regarding whether he'll get any of
Chris' fans votes .