I'm almost in complete agreement with DR Matt H about SWEENEY TODD.
The audience I was in, and I, were indeed laughing at Mrs. Lovett's jokes - and it was a sparse audience, yet attentive.
I believe that one of the reasons the film is drawing such a diverse reaction is that it is a film which requires the audience to PAY ATTENTION. To get the lyrics, to get the jokes, to get the subtlety, attention must be paid - and most of today's audiences don't want to pay attention, they want the instant gratification of a popcorn movie. SWEENEY TODD is a lot of things, but, popcorn it isn't!
There are a few things I missed from the stage show, and I'm not so sure that "God That's God" works as well without a chorus.
Still, it's not a movie which takes place in the pupil of Toby's eye, nor is it a static filmed musical, the leads are the appropriate ages not a generation too old for their roles.
SWEENEY TODD is now my favorite Tim Burton film - it's his vision, but, it enhances the brilliance of Sondheim's music and lyrics without reverting to tricks to make a film musical sing.