DR Elmore,
Both SAVING GRACE and IN PLAIN SIGHT do very, very well in the ratings. Not as well as THE CLOSER, of course, but certainly they do nicely. I stopped watching SAVING GRACE last year about 7 episodes in. As much as I loved both Joel and Ken as her boy friends/lovers, I just couldn't stand her character, and the religious material running through it was also a turn-off.
IN PLAIN SIGHT just didn't have enough of a mystery for me, and I really hated the sister and mother characters.