It's tough to tell from the promos - but the music from SMASH doesn't seem to be Broadway like - more American Idol content and singing style. It might be a vehicle for selling LOTS of music downloads....kind of like GLEE.
And then there's the luminescence of Miss MESSing.
DR JRand - Have you watched the pilot online? Most of the songs are written by Debra Messing and Christian Borle, er, I mean Scott Wittman and Marc Shaiman. So, the sound is very much of "today's Broadway".
I like what I've heard so far, although, I will admit that nothing has truly impressed me, but I think that may be on purpose.
*I actually liked the choice of "Beautiful" for an audition song. There was something very smart about that choice. Alas, I didn't like the auto-tuning.
**I'm wondering if we'll be hearing any songs from the writing teams "current" hit show, "Heaven & Earth" (which, apparently is at the Shubert Theatre).