When that was over, I decided I wanted to continue watching more "Making of" documentaries of Hitchcock films, so I started with TOPAZ, probably my least favorite Hitchcock movie next to UNDER CAPRICORN. They didn't have a standard making-of featurette. Instead, the disc offered "An Appreciation" of the movie by Leonard Maltin. I don't think I had ever even bothered to watch this before, so I did today. I understand the points he makes in defense of the movie (and it was interesting reading comments from the film's disastrous first preview), but I'm not buying it. Yes, there are a couple of bravura sequences, but it's a long, slow crawl to get to them, and then you get to that very unsatisfying ending. Nope, not a favorite.
Funny that you should bring up TOPAZ, as I watched it (and the appreciation) for the first time last night!
I'm not as down on the film as you are, but not quite as glowing as Maltin is either.
There are several things I agree with Maltin on regarding TOPAZ, first and foremost being that it could have used "stars;" until last night I had only got as far as "the china shop" sequence, never even making it to the Copenhagen department store.
I thought that the characters were quite interesting (that Leon Uris created them probably helped) and that the premise was fascinating.
Yet, there is nothing truly Hitchcockian about TOPAZ, is there? Except for the two scenes given remembrance by Maltin, the film could have been the handiwork of any European director of that era.
I did not for one moment buy John Vernon as a Cuban - and those piercing eyes!
I did like Dany Robin, though her character was utterly predictable and made up to be a classic "Hitchcock Blonde."
Karin Dor was likeable and given the most Hitchcockian moment in the film - and that is an awesome moment!
The men, except for Michel Subor as the young husband were quite interchangeble; now, Michel was quite the piece of eye-candy!
I would have prefered that John Forsythe had switched roles with Frederick Stafford.
Still, I am happy that I finally made it through TOPAZ.