First: "American Idol" sucked last night. Second, if last night's show was the first you watched, please refrain from presuming all the shows are like that one. They have NONE OF THEM been as bad as last night's.
Fox did not put the contestants through so many mandatory "theme" nights in past competitions. Last year, I recall, they did Burt Bacharach, and his songs are not easy to sing for most singers.
Elton John wrote his songs for himself to sing. Manilow, too. Ditto Estefan. Great songs for them, individually, but few singers can move from one to the other easily. Chaos MUST ensue.
The pity is that the singers in this batch DO have good voices and have proven that in past shows. But they're carted all over creation daily in special appearances, and they are forced, week after week, to adapt themselves to singing styles different from what their personal styles are. As a result, they are not showcased to their best advantage and it gives Simon -- who may be correct in his reaction to specific performances -- an opportunity to be "brutally honest" about a performance even Britney Spears and Justin Timberlake could not have pulled off with the rehearsal time they give the contestants. My point: The critiques are not fair given the circumstances under which the competition is being conducted. That's why Paula bickers with Simon so much, I think. She seems to get it...to take that into account. And that may be why she's more generous in her assessments of some onerously bad performances.
I think the whole show needs an overhaul.
As for Elton John's "racist" remarks -- to hell with Elton John. And don't shove that "Sir" down my throat here in the US of A. He's totally nuts. He also said that the three divas were consistently in the bottom three. Rubbish. Had that been true they'd all be gone. Each had been there at least once, but that's the way things go for all the contestants.
The three divas' fans let them down. A couple of weeks earlier, they were all in the top three. Unfortunately, with free, unlimited voting, the fans of the less talented desperately waged a battle to save their favorites from being the one to leave. The result was that none of the divas' fans thought it necessary to vote hundreds of times each, and Jennifer was lost in that way...IMO.