In the spirit of that's what makes a horse race, I have got to say that DAMN YANKEES (which as a kid I pronounced as DAM-N YANKESS) remains one of my favorite movie musicals of all time. On of the main reasons I loved it was because it was so very theatrical. It was probably the only movie musical, I can remember, that retained almost the entire Broadway cast, with the exception of Stephen Douglass. Growing up in Tacoma, Washington, I had little exposure to Broadway theater, nor could I afford to buy OBC LPs, and the staged quality of the show was absolutely wonderful to me. And then, of course, there was Gwen Verdon! What a talent....what legs...what a STAR!
And it didn't hurt that Tab Hunter was one of my first crushes (at the tender age of eleven, or something like that)!