Is there anything wrong with wanting and choosing to be primarily judged/chosen based on your talent alone?
Well, no,...but...
If we add to "talent" the ability to engage a multitude of avid fans we get a better picture of the nature of these contests.
Record producers are not concerned with who can make the "best" records, rather who can sell the most records.
A Broadway Star must have a certain "wow" that sells tickets.
In most of the "talent" categories, posters seem to rank Austin over Max. If I were buying an Album, it would probably be one by Austin; if I were buying tickets to Grease, I'd much prefer to see Max than Austin - Austin is just
"so perfect", but Max has that engaging
"bad boy" persona that personifies Danny.
Something the TV judges get that the viewers do not is a sense of how a performer projects "live".
I suspect all the attention the Grease show has garnered will translate into initial ticket sales.
der Brucer