"American Idol" -- I personally think Fantasia is the best entertainer the show has ever had.
Last night, though, they were not being harsh with Fantasia about her first song, they were being critical of the arrangement -- in the middle of that criticism, they praised her for the fact that she made it good anyway.
Diana did not sing her last song very well -- she got way off key and it took her a while to bring it back around.
My main criticism of Diana is that every song is a screaming song -- it's always uptempo and written to throw one's vocal cords into ultra-shock. Third time, last night, was the charm. She simply could not sustain that type of song three times in one hour. (Another irritant is that she always starts these songs by rushing onstage and yelling, "Come on, y'all..." Gimme a break!
Fantasia mixed it up, and she's been doing that throughout the competition. Diana hasn't except on Big Band night when she did a surprising "Someone to Watch Over Me."
In regards to how America voted, I don't think the judges' comments will have been very favorable for Fantasia. Every time they've ever been up front about her (or LaToya) being the best or pre-annointing her as the next Idol, she's ended up in the bottom two. Simon will go on and on, praising Fantasia by degrading everyone else. He cannot give a compliment that doesn't demean someone else. I think the public lashes out for that reason. I know I do.
I tried and tried and tried to call last night and could not get through but once -- EACH -- to vote.
I don't care which one gets it. I think they both deserve it, despite the judges who, once again, sounded pre-rehearsed in their commentaries.
On a sour note, has anyone else noticed that the judges always seem to think that each performance is about "them"? As soon as a performer has sung and the audience is cheering, Randy Jackson exhibits little patience in letting the applause die down until he can be heard, and thus we get, "Fantasia! Fantasia! Yo! Yo!"....meant to grab her attention away from her fans and to shut her fans up.
Simon, on the other hand, when he led off the critiquing a couple of weeks ago, just told the audience to "Shut up." (Overheard many weeks ago after Jasmine finished a song, Simon was caught on an open mike saying, "They would stand up for THAT, wouldn't they!")
Some things cannot be controlled.