I thought the film of the musical of The Producers was terrible - couldn't even make it all the way through - flat, unfunny, and really poorly directed, IMO. The original still makes me laugh out loud, but that's what makes horse racing. I used to have an acquaintence from high school who was Mel's secretary at Fox, so I got to see rough cut screenings of Young Frankenstein, High Anxiety, Silent Movie and History of the World, Part One. Even in rough cut it was obvious that Young Frankenstein was brilliant - the others were not so hot and never improved much beyond the rough cut. I think after the screening of Young Frankenstein they shaved about ten minutes off, and at that point there was no John Morris score, and boy did that add a lot to the film.