DR Elmore: It's not just singers who are entering the workplace without classical training.
Film composition, these days, requires little more (seemingly) than a knowledge of synth keyboards. It's more "noise application" than anything, IMO...and taking something someone else has written, changing a note or two, and passing it off as something different enough to escape a lawsuit. And you get to put your name on it, too!
The trouble with "American Idol" is that they select contestants from among thousands of wannabe singers. There are no requirements re: training...they just pick people who can put over part of a song on a day when they're hearing thousands.
As soon as the competition is underway, they either chastise someone who has had training (making it sound like a bad thing) or they chastise the contestants for their inabilitiy to put over a song...yet there is no evidence that the show is providing any modicum of training to assist them at all.
So...whatchagonnado?