Re: "American Idol":
SPOILER -- if you haven't seen it!
Last night was a breath of fresh air...as it should have been. The past couple of weeks have been tiresome, to the extreme, with the badly chosen "theme" weeks of music from the 21st century and the Queen stuff.
I agreed with nearly everything Simon said last night with three exceptions:
1. Elliot was superb...and was more winning than ever in his presentation. What is Simon missing that he would chastise Elliot for displaying no personality?
2. While Katherine was, indeed, in a "league" of her own last night, it was a league below the better singers. Katherine was "okay"...not the best rendition of that song -- and not the best song choice, IMO. Diana DeGarmo sang it two seasons ago with much more power and style. I think Katherine believes herself to be quite the talent. She seems too "on" and a bit smug. So far, I've not "fallen in love" with anything she's sung.
3. Poor Ace. He was far from "charming," IMO. I could barely hear him over the orchestra. "That's All" isn't a favorite of mine, but I knew when I heard him tell Stewart his choice of song that it was because it was another song he could "coo." Hated the hair.
Kellie was a delight, despite the snafu with getting ahead of the orchestra. I'm not sure why she didn't take a second to settle back into the accompaniment, but it's lack of experience that's the culprit, I'm sure.
For the first part of the song, I thought she was "delightful"....almost like hearing Monroe singing a song in a film. Simon DID get me to laugh with his comment about how she could have just left out "Bewitched" and "Bothered" and stuck with "Bewildered."
I fear for Elliot, since folks tend to listen to Simon rather than form their own opinions of what they've just heard.