Watched the first hour of the IDOL finale. They really have made the show much more entertaining than in previous years. Lots of big name guest stars (Meat Loaf, Al Jureau, Dionne Warwick, Prince) in addition to the Idols doing a lot of singing, too.
I flipped off it once LOST started, but LOST went to a commercial at 9:55, and I was able to see the announcement of the winner. I also recorded the show so I can watch the entire second hour tomorrow.
I think the winner was the most reasonable choice.