Last night's "Idol" was a very mixed bag for me. I wasn't nearly as high as Randy was on the level of performances, although I agree Elliott did two of his all-time best vocals.
Chris continued his "Johnny One-Note" ways...and that's not to say I don't think he's good. He's better than good...the trouble is he's always delivering his songs in the same way...with the same intensity...with no distinction between power rock and ballad. And that has gotten EXTREMEly old for me.
Taylor...two horrendous performances, IMO. The first one seemed not only a joke, but a hideous self-caricature. There simply was too much song for Taylor to sustain his schtick, IMO.
Katherine: She's radiant, well-coifed, beautifully dressed...and she doesn't bring a memorable performance to the stage...ever. There was no problem with song choices...that last song should have been a knockout...instead, as Simon said, she overdid it. She hit a couple of notes that nearly gave me a seizure.
If Chris leaves, things brighten considerably for Elliott. If Kat leaves, it becomes a testosterone showdown next week.