Matt, I am curious. When you review a show like 7TH HEAVEN that you so thoroughly dislike; do you slam the show because it isn't your cup of tea, or are you reviewing it more for the quality of the DVD and the extras that are lncluded?
I can send you a link once the review goes up so you can see for yourself (it's going up later tonight), but if you want to spare yourself the trouble, I can answer here.
I admit such a show is not my cup of tea in the review (though I try to be as objective as possible by finding the good among the bad. I have rarely flat out panned anything. There's usually something positive to say if one looks for it. Being nasty and sarcastic is easy, but I don't go for that kind of blanket panning.) Still, no reviewer worth his salt is going to like everything, so the thing about reading reviewers is if you're going to depend on them to guide your viewing choices, then you find one who seems to jive with your own likes and dislikes. Or you if you don't need guidance for that, you read them for information and fun.
My reviews, as are all the reviews on better sites, critique the material as well as the quality of the video, audio, and bonuses. I think all of those things are vital to someone wanting to decide whether to rent or buy a certain title.