TOD:
Many years ago I read all the Holmes stories and greatly enjoyed most of them, but a couple of favorites were the ones that take place in the U.S. -- the Gold Rush one and isn't there one around Salt Lake City? Oy! You can see how much of it I've retained over the years. It's a little embarrassing. I have one of those big annotated sets and every time I glance at it I vow to reread them all.
As far as films go, I'm even more delinquent. There are many I haven't seen. With such scant experience in these matters, I'll fall back on Rathbone as my standard Holmes, but definitely Cushing, too, in BASKERVILLES.