BK,
I'm a little confused about your review of the the MARTY disc.
I have not seen this new edition and am perfectly satisfied with the old MGM/UA DVD I've had for years.
Granted, not all DVD or Blu-ray transfers are ideal, but when you disagree with the statement "It's better than nothing," are you really saying that if, say MARTY, cannot be duplicated to meet your standards, it should not be made available to the public at all?
There are several movies that I like for which I have less than ideal DVD transfers, but what I do have are the best (as far as I know) that is available. And, I would rather have these than nothing.
BTW: It's amazing how sharp a DVD looks when it's played on a Blu-Ray player on a Hi-Def TV.