My thoughts on PIAZZA and SPAMALOT (not that anyone asked): I think PIAZZA is a breath of fresh air on Broadway right now. It's one of the most romantic new scores I've heard in a long, long time and it just makes you want to get kicked in the head by a Shetland pony and fall in love - though it took more than one listen before I thought so. In fact, I was bored by it the first time I saw the show. After listening to the recording multiple times, however, I can't wait to go back and see it. I think the orchestral arrangements are gorgeous - they remind me of a 1950's film score with the harps and strings and the loveliness. Yes, it all sort of sounds of one vein, but...well, it IS all of one vein.
I have no doubt that Mr. Hochman's orchestrations are brilliant for SPAMALOT. I've seen the show. I've got the recording. I don't remember his orchestrations, though. Maybe that's a good thing - orchestrations shouldn't beat you over the head, I suppose - but honestly, I didn't notice them. I was too busy being horrified by how boring the leading men were and waiting for Sara Ramirez to come back onstage. She's the funniest thing on Broadway right now, though Sherie Rene Scott gives her a run for her money. I'll have to go back to the CD and listen for the orchestrations 'cause I really don't remember them at all.