RLP, why do you get so riled when JRand expresses his dislike of a performer? He is just funnin' for crying out loud! Jack knows of my love (love, love) for Gene Kelly, but heck, I don't mind his making with the remarks about him.
Now, just calm down young man!
There's having an opinion and then there's engaging in an ongoing litany of bilious spite.
We get it. He dislikes Gene Kelly.
But to call Kelly pretentious (!), and to dismiss his dancing in AAIP as dumb, is really asking for a response from someone who disagrees with him.
You are far more understanding than I, MBarnum. JRand can be a choreographer, have his own sensibilities about what is good and not good, and he can dislike the dancing of Gene Kelly, but if he's going to put himself out there and make just plain ugly remarks about it, it begs a retort.
If Jrand is free to make such remarks, I see no reasons why I should not be free to do the same.
Of course, he knows how I react to such pronouncements about successful celebrities and will no doubt have a good laugh that he's once again baited me with his wry musings.