I agree down the line on "Rags." Strouse has written his own books and lyrics for shows, so he should have been working along with the rest of them. Still, in his defense, outside of the performances (I still remember Judy Kuhn's haunted eyes as she sang the title song on the Tonys), Strouse's music is the best thing about the show.
The book was by Joseph Stein, and there were a couple of clinker numbers:
Hard to be a Prince
Yankee Boy
Wanting
The second act stumbled along, but the "Four Sunny Rooms" duet was delightful. In the first act, "Brand New World" which should have become a huge production number was still delightful enough to make you think the show would be a hit.
Rags is an important show for me for many reasons. I played it in 1995 at a local high school. I fell in love with the score, and with my first ever love. The relationship lasted a mere 6 weeks because of some immaturity on my part and after the break-up,
Rags was difficult to listen to for the past 15 years. (there's a book in here somewhere) - anyway... recently, that person has appeared in my life again and miraculously,
Rags is easier to listen to again, and I'm glad of that because I've missed it. No - nothing will ever happen again with the first love, but the fact that they have returned to my life is enough. I happen to love the song "Wanting", it may be crappy, but I love the haunting strings. Yeah, there's a book here somewhere....