I really like Scarlet Pimpernel, especially "Into the Fire," which is a number I found so thrilling that it transformed the evening in the theater the first time I saw the show in previews,
There's that one song "Where's the Girl" which has a section that always reminds me of the pop song "Would you like to ride my beautiful balloon" but I like the song anyway
Funny you mention "Where's the Girl." That is one song that ALWAYS reminds me of something I can't quite put my finger on, but it sounds like a mixture of several Barry Manilow songs—"Even Now" and "Could it Be Magic," and maybe something else as well. As a rabid Jimmy Webb fan, I didn't notice the "Up Up and Away" similarity, but I'll listen for that. One thing is for sure—"Where's the Girl" is derivative as hell!
I like "Into the Fire" a lot. Very passionate! Lyrically, it always makes me think of "Walk Through the Fire" from "Once More With Feeling," the Buffy the Vampire musical. Musically, though, it would fit perfectly in Les Miz. In fact, at the very end of the song, when he sings, "Onward ho!" I always substitute, "Jean Valjean!"
What would be the next logical Frank Wildhorn musical to discover? He seems to have hundreds of them! Jekyll & Hyde, Cyrano, Civil War, Dracula, Monte Cristo, Tears of Heaven, Bonnie & Clyde, et al. Are any as good as Pimpernel?