TOD
Of the several productions of GYPSY I've seen (none of which I'm sorry to say were any of the Broadway ones), the most recent was the best -- a community production last year in Torrington, CT at the wonderful renovated 1930s movie palace, the Warner Theatre. The woman who played Rose could not have been more believable or brilliant in every way. But everyone else was very nearly her equal, and I had to sit there and eat my heart out because I'd been asked to play in the pit, couldn't because of schedule conflicts, and the orchestra was spot on perfect and thrilling as well.
And then I've seen a few stinkers. But the thing about the stage version is that it's perfect -- book, songs, orchestration -- and something of that always comes through, however excruciating the performance.
I'd grown up loving every note of the original cast album, and when I first saw the movie I was thrilled to see the thing unfold on screen but somewhat less thrilled with some of the music. I bought the soundtrack LP, which I still have, but it wasn't one I returned to much over the years. Now I can much better appreciate all that's great about it, and I shall do exactly that very soon. (I spot-checked the Blu-ray when it arrived yesterday, and it looks and sounds fabulous.)
Have to agree about the extreme key changes acting as black holes and sucking in everything around them. But as we have all learned to accept here or there, "it is what it is", and that Warner production is something to behold on a good screen and sound system.
And to portray that (perfect) original overture being played/dubbed onscreen under the main titles = pure genius. (If I recall, it's unaltered, but I'll check it closely when I watch next time.)