TOD:
CABARET. Bought the cast album when new and played it to death. Bought the vocal score and played that to death. Sadly, I never got to NYC or anywhere else to see anything close to the original production. Jumping ahead a few years, I, too, was disappointed in the film because it was such a departure from the stage musical. I appreciate it now, especially in its beautiful new incarnation on Blu-ray, but back then it just flew right over my head. CABARET came along in exactly the year I was taught how to properly handle and care for LPs -- in fact, it was the first cast album to have been so treated by me -- and that very piece o' vinyl is still on my shelf and still plays beautifully today.
CHICAGO. Saw the touring production, cold (I hadn't listened to it at all) at the Dorothy Chandler in L.A., but the silliest thing marred my appreciation of it that evening. I'd recently gotten my first contact lenses -- I think just a few weeks prior -- and was so excited to be wearing them and enjoying that beautiful new clear full-range vision at the show...but they were just "off" that night, irritating me in some way, and I let myself be continually distracted by it. Incredibly, that made CHICAGO irritate me, and when I got the album somewhat later and started really appreciating it, I regretted the error of my ways. I love the show now, regardless of the eyewear I happen to be sporting.
KISS OF THE SPIDER WOMAN. Fell instantly in love with the CD. When I learned that Chita Rivera was to be leaving the show, I hustled and got a ticket for her closing night, and that is without question one of those nights in the theater I will never forget. The impact of score (which I was totally crazy about, but had only heard out of context) and what I was seeing blew me away, and I wonder to this day why I didn't have Ms. Rivera sign my program as she chatted leisurely and appreciatively with the relatively small assembly of admirers afterward. Several years later I jumped at the chance to piano/conduct a small production that in general wasn't all that bad, but did suffer at the hands of a lead gal who didn't really "get" it.