I am curious what other DRs thought about yesterday's women's figure skating long program?? Especially the scores for the top 3.
The placements for the long program were mostly correct. However, I do not believe they were correct in the short program. Adelina Sotnikova was scored way too high for her technically "light" short program. And where did those high component (artistry/presentation) scores come from for her?
Someone on the internet today suggested Mao Asada's rise from 16th to 6th was a gift based on her reputation. I took exception to the remark. She skated a brilliant long program filled with grace, artistry and technical sophistication. She leapfrogged over lesser skaters for her final placement. She earned it, IMO.
Ashley Wagner takes herself way too seriously, IMO. She scares me a bit. I also don't enjoy watching her skate. I'm thinking the judges find her a bit much, as well.
I don't think Sotnikova came anywhere NEAR matching Carolina Kostner's component elements and a "fair" assessment of the former's skate would likely have seen the same three on top but in different positions.