TOD:
I really love some pickles and am "eh" about many others.
Sadly, I don't think I've ever had a homemade pickle in my life! For store brands, I long ago gravitated to the Claussen type refrigerated ones for the most part.
Does "gherkins" refer to the dark sweet pickles? Those were a childhood staple but I find them uninteresting now. Same with regular old dill or "kosher dill", though I find dill chips are the proper thing for burgers.
Claussen's garlic slices are a favorite, for eating by themselves or adding to various cold cut sandwiches.
I'll buy any tub of half sours that looks like it'll live up to the kind of deli pickle I'm most crazy about (I do love it when you can tell they actually started life as a cucumber, and usually eat all of those out of the bowl at a deli before anyone else has a chance at them).
Pickle relish is something I tend to ignore, except in combination with other things to make a hot dog taste more like a Chicago dog.
Bread 'n' butter pickles have always been a special treat, going back to childhood, and I will gobble up any pile of those you set in front of me. I'm not sure I even get around to adding them to anything.