That said, I had to overanalyze Company for a class and ended up with a 75-page paper on the show.
I agree with most everything BK wrote except for one thing. I think the audience loves Tick Tock. Michael Bennett certainly choreographed the heck out of it, but since the music wasn't Sondheim's (it was Shire's, if I recall correctly), I can understand why he would want it cut.
I actually like the show without Tick Tock because, without it, the sex between Bobby and April becomes just another scene of empty, meaningless sex. Depressing for the audience, to be sure, but it shows how dreary Bobby's life really is.