SPOILER
LADIES' FREE SKATE
SPOILER
I don't have any problems with the end results of yesterday's long program...but I take issue with the judges for giving Arakawa higher "component program" (i.e. "artistic") marks than Sasha Cohen. Arakawa's spins were limited, somewhat cumbersome and a few were "alop." And that doughnot spin...she did it three or four times...whassupwidat? VARIETY is very much needed. She's a beautiful lady, statuesque...has that Katarina Witt appeal on ice...but one fall on on those jumps and she has nothing to fall back on, so to speak...she could not have overcome the fall that Sasha took and still have medaled, IMO.
Slutskaya has the same problem..only she also has NO choreography of note...it's just a dizzying series of dashes to her next jump...her spins are wild abandon unleashed...and excellent. She chose high-energy music this year and it very much worked against her in that it left no after-glow with the viewers. As highly overrated as I've thought she has been the past five years, I was disappointed that she had nothing more to offer than she displayed last night.
As for the oft-reported comment that she believed she should have been given the gold in Salt Lake City, the truth is she didn't earn it. Her performance was pretty lackluster. I cannot imagine anyone watching that event and thinking Irina skated better than anyone. I didn't even think her skate was better than Michelle Kwan's (who, ruinously, changed her terrific program skated at nationals...which included a final series of things like a split, a falling leaf and other fast footwork...totally eliminating the emotional rush that progam had at its end) and Michelle fell once, but skated beautifully. No! Sara Hughes skated THE program of that competition...one day I hope Irina realizes this and gets over herself.