AMERICAN IDOL tonight:
The two Davids once again were the highlights of the show. I typically didn't like Jason Castro, still don't get his appeal in terms of talent. I thought all of the girls had problematic performances.
Carly's voice seemed weird tonight as if she were struggling to make it do something. There wasn't any mention of her being under the weather, but I was very unimpressed with her song tonight and fear this may be the end. Syesha also tried to trick up her rendition with all this melisma, but it was VERY off-pitch noodling around with notes and sounded REALLY horrible (and the tape editors used part of it in the wrap-up at the end of the hour. This may be a problem for her, too). I also didn't like Brooke much tonight.
So, Kristy Lee, despite some off pitch notes, actually had the strongest of the four female vocals, a BIG surprise (and the phrasing and sustain on her last notes were superb).
Bottom three: Carly (going home), Syesha, Brooke.