Your comments on the RCA OBC, please.
der Brucer
The OBC recording is pathetically short, and I wish the RCA producer had the foresight/clout of Goddard Lieberson to record the complete show on 3 LPs with that fantastic cast. The show is thorough-composed, and the album can give you a section of, say, "Helen Is Always Willin'" but it cannot show you how brilliantly the melodies in that song are developed in a 10-minute scene.
The entire opening "Nothing Ever Happens In Angel's Roost," takes the harmonies and melody and runs rampant through a number of moods: Helen's boredom, the three townsladies' chauvinism, Mother Hare's mysticism and cynicism, and Penelope's elation that the Spanish-American War is over and the boys are coming home, at which point "My Love Is On the Way" ends the sequence, which is about 7-8 minutes long.
The only spot on the OBC that shows how some of the piece is composed is truncated "Judgment of Paris." The theme is on the sax, Mrs Juniper's Angel food sequence is a variation on the theme, and it's about 75% recorded from the entrance of Paris to the can-can off. Unfortunately, the opening agitato sequence with the balloon is gone (very BIG COUNTRY), as is the ladies' first appearance with their baked goods and the introduction of the theme. I think the bits and pieces on the OBC arewell-performed and I'm grateful we have what we have. Alas, it's about one-third of the score.