I admit that I haven't read the notes yet, but I had to comment on last night's discussion of DVD site "reviewers" by quoting from one of the reviewer's comments on ALICE IN WONDERLAND and bk's follow-up:
"Black levels seemed nicely deep and dark, and shadow detail was fine. Contrast was solid as well, as whites were pure and clean."
Of course, in this one paragraph we get all the other catch-phrases - i.e. Black levels, shadow detail, clean whites, and solid contrast. I mean, I just scratch my head in wonderment."
Since the reviewer is critiquing an ANIMATED film, I think the discussion of shadow detail is absurd. All of the shadows were DRAWN in and are exactly the levels of darkness the animators wanted them to be.
And as for the reviewer of PLANET OF THE APES (actually two of them since part of it was the orignal review and the other part by the site's editor), can you believe this site did not hire me as one of their critics? I applied something like three years ago when they were looking for some new critics and despite 25 years of professionally reviewing films, television, theater, and home video, they couldn't use me. (Said I was next in line if they lost another critic; ha!)