Re: David Archuleta: Yes, he'll be successful, but more in the Clay Aiken vein rather than Chris Daughtry.
That's apples and oranges for me. I don't think Chris Daughtry would have been the perfect AI winner at all. Elliot Yamin was my favorite of that season. Daughty slung the mike stand around and bellowed out his songs, and I guess a lot of folks like that.
To his credit, Daughtry did a phenomenal Star-Spangled Banner to open the Super Bowl (was that the one where he sang it? Or was it to start last year's World Series?). At any rate, he was very, very good.
Clay Aiken...say or think what you like, but he is the most bankable AI contestant ever. He has had MAJOR concert success and has won awards (not like Carrie Underwood or Kelly Clarkson, of course) and seems to be pleasing Broadway audiences with his stint in "Spamalot."
He's sold 6 million CDs, too. That's not on a par with the two ladies I've mentioned, but then his concert earnings are much greater than CD earnings. I'm thinking Clay is one very rich man right now. And where, oh where, is Ruben Studdard except when AI hauls him out of his obscurity to sing another forgettable song on the show?
Archuleta is far more "viable", IMO, than Clay Aiken because he's very good-looking, he has stage presence and, more importantly, he projects sex appeal to the screaming, adoring fans. It's not a sex appeal that makes you wince, either.
David Cook has very odd hair. Maybe that's why he'll win.