BK,
When I reluctantly found myself at the center of the last maelstrom that happened here, I said at the time no matter what happened to me or the other individual involved, most people would move on and that your site would continue to flourish. How many years ago was that? Seems I was right.
A small few chose to listen to only one side and left, most either ferreted out the truth or didn't care about personal dynamics of a private matter dragged out in a public forum and didn't let it affect their participation. Some, as both you and I know, even discovered the truth of things later on in no uncertain terms.
But, as predicted, all the sturm and drang ultimately had very little effect on this site. Those who left, it was their loss. The rest remained a relatively happy bunch who enjoy each other's company, debates, and camaraderie.
You'll know when it's time to close down the site. And it will have nothing to do with nonsense like this.
I will say I'm really bewildered how a person thinks that sharing an individual's unflattering private email with you, obviously not meant for your eyes, will gain him readership to his own blog. Great way to start an online relationship or any relationship...by betraying that person's privacy and trust in order to embarrass both the email writer and you. I think that alone would be enough to deter anyone else from communicating with him, for fear that anything expressed in confidence might be exposed so he can score points.
Your pal,
Pogue