DR Der Brucer,
A.How exactly do they prove that someone is gay?
B. And if the people know they will be thrown out why do they admit to it?
C.Or why do they enroll in the first place?
D.It's absolutely amazing that this is allowed to go on.
E. And re: your young friend, I think him living with his family is probably not a good thing right now. Hopefully his parents will come to accept him, but right now they are not able to do that. Maybe he could give them some books to read.
Answers:
A. If your observed doing “it” with another – they gotcha! If they catch A&B doing “it”, they often suggest that they will be treated more leniently if they will reveal the names of others with whom they’ve done “it”.
B. If you have been caught in the act, you can be Court Martialed, sent to Federal Prison for 5 years and be given a Bad Conduct Discharge.
Some discussion:
Under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Article 125, Sodomy is defined as:
Any person subject to this chapter who engages in unnatural carnal copulation with another person of the same or opposite sex or with an animal is guilty of sodomy. Penetration, however slight, is sufficient
to complete the offense.
…
Explanation. It is unnatural carnal copulation for a person to take into that person’s mouth or anus the sexual organ of another person or of an animal; or to place that person’s sexual organ in the mouth or anus of another person or of an animal; or to have carnal copulation in any opening of the body, except the sexual parts, with another person; or to have carnal copulation with an animal.
Note: Consensual oral sex between a husband and a wife is just a punishable as all the other nasties. I leave “carnal copulation in any opening of the body, except the sexual parts” to more imaginative minds.
Now, in place of a Court Martial, you may be subjected to an Administrative Discharge for really specific reasons like “convenience of the government” “personality incompatible with military service” and other specifics .An Administrative Discharge may be Honorable, General (under honorable conditions), or General (under other than honorable –OTH – conditions. Dishonorable Discharges can only be awarded by a Court Martial.
They government will often bargain with a member concerning the nature of his/her discharge. Confess – and we will give you a General Discharge under Honorable conditions; fight us and, if we have a good case, we’ll send to a Court Martial and potential 5 years and a BCD, if our case is a little weak, we’ll send you to an Administrative Hearing (which has significantly relaxed rules of evidence) and recommend you get a General-OTH discharge.
The key issue is the character of the discharge: if you can wrangle a General (under Honorable conditions) you’ll face few consequences in civilian life; an OTH discharge will cost you most, if not all of your benefits, and a BCD is a Federal Felony conviction on your record for life.
C. An appointment to a Service academy is a very prestigious thing (not to mention a free, exceptionally valuable, education). Family pressure and financial needs will often drive a youngster to assume he can keep a secret for a few years. (When I was that age, “coming out” was unthinkable, Military or not, today the kids have a few more options, but there is still the family/financial pressure. Also, there are many cases where the young adult does not act on his orientation until his college years.)
D. Nothing in the arena of man’s cruelty to man amazes me
E. For a teen-ager with no particular job skills, going it alone is generally not an option. (and considering that many Midshipmen come from sheltered homes and have no idea how to use a washer or a dryer or an iron, or how to cook a meal – going it alone would be a real “experience”).
If the parents were amenable to reading some “good books” most of our problem would be solved.
der Brucer (thanx for your support)