Re: last night's repeat American Idol, I don't think it was really fair. Yes I think it was right to scrap tuesday's votes. But I think they should have just not eliminated anybody this week and then eliminated two next week.
People like Nikko, who are just okay, got complete raves last night. Because they did not speak to every judge for each contestant. So all people got to hear was Paula's over the top praise for Nikko. Yet the only person we got to hear for Nadia was Simon slamming her. Even though she wasn't very good on Tuesday, she is still one of the best. And I just didn't think the way they did things seemed fair.
The worst infraction was Mikalah (who probably would have gone home after Tuesday's votes). But her plea last night was very sympathetic and sweet. And I'm thinking her personality and that whole chat thing they did with her is gonna have an impact on the votes.