DR MattH, re: the judges' comments. Didn't they suggest Nadia was in trouble BEFORE Scott had even performed? I'm not sure how I feel about what Scott said to Simon. I never liked him (Scott). But was even more put off after the abuse allegations re: his child's mom. But more than that, since then he's been more distant and not as nice.
But re: his comments. I think that he was partially right. I mean yes, it is something for him to be up there. It cannot be easy being a nobody and then having to perform in front of a huge crowd (and 30M viewers). But I don't see why he couldn't just accept Simon's comments. If Simon thought he had problems in certain areas of the song THEN MAYBE HE SHOULD LISTEN TO THAT.
I hate that Paula (and the crowd for that matter) are not interested in hearing any negative comments.
And btw, when Simon said Constantine was "astonishing" did he mean astonishingly good or bad?

(I know he meant good, but geez he should have clarified).
Also, re: who will be voted out, I think it's clear from last week that Paula/Randy's praise of Vonzell/Nikko made no difference. So I'll bet there will be at least one surprise in the B3.
Also2, after praising Carrie like there was no tomorrow, Simon has been quite negative towards her in the past couple of weeks. I am trying to figure out if he is purposely trying to tone down his comments (because I know I was finding it very annoying). Btw, am I the only one who is less than thrilled by carrie? I do like her. ANd i'm sure she is very popular (and will probably win). But there is something about her that seems sort of stuck up.