June 17th: It seems everyone who has seen ONCE loves it. Is this play based on the movie? Keith & I didn't like the movie at all & especially didn't enjoy the music.
June 18th: I'm surprised on DR JMK responded to my question regarding ONCE.
Jane, I'm responding so you don't think we're ignoring you.
Yes, the musical Once, opening tonight on Broadway, is based on the movie. If you didn't like the movie you won't like the musical. They made some minor changes to the story which make it more theatrical and they added two new songs but, basically, the movie has been transformed to a stage musical.
I think Celtic/Folk/Roots music can be an acquired taste. That being said, I think the music in the movie and on stage added to the beauty of both pieces.
I respect the fact that you didn't like the movie. You're not the only one (or you and JMK are not the only ones) but it has garnered more praise than dislikes. It isn't a matter of right or wrong. That kind of response is rude and, I feel, useless. I liked it. You didn't like it. As BK says often, that's the horse race (or something like that). I've had the idea that I'm wrong because I didn't like something, or "I'm sorry you didn't get it" thrown at me too many times to buy the argument. It's art. Many people have different feelings and interpretations of art. It's not a one size fits all affair.
I don't know that there is much more to say about it. Again, I'm perfectly fine with you not liking the movie. There are MANY movies that people here adore which I can't sit through (The Court Jester being one, the pestle sequence makes me run screaming from the room). I just chalk it up to my eclectic tastes
