DR ELMORE and CP - your comments on Ms. Striesand RE:my comments, have been noted. And there is a LOT of truth in what you both write.
DR CP - put me firmly in Rosemary Clooney's camp. Rosemary, Doris, Betty Hutton, and all those great band singers and vocalists in the 1950's didn't feel the need to "personalize" a song by changing the rhythm or notes - but nonetheless they made songs "theirs" with their distinctive voices and phrasing...
Doris Day in particular, I think, needs to be listened to more today - I think she is dismissed because she is "movie star" - but she can sing like nobody else. Rosemary Clooney is also in a class by herself. And even the "second rung" of 50's ladies like Giselle McKenzie, Polly Bergen, and Jane Morgan still sound contemporary and fresh.
I've said before - and I'll say it again - years ago, when I was nine, I was one of the kids in a "Starlight Musicals" production of GYPSY - a traveling tab version that traversed the Midwest in the summer....local talent was picked up for the smaller parts, including the kids.
Giselle McKenzie was Rose - and I have NEVER heard anyone sing "Everything's Coming Up Roses" and "Rose's Turn" with more power or real emotion. She had the audience in the palm of her hand - and could get a laugh with a look or bat of her eyes. And she was great to all of us local people, too.