I called in some votes for Katharine last night. Her line was not busy. I still think she has the best voice of the women (but Paris isn't far behind and neither is Mandisa).
Kinnik wasn't good, and she might very well go. I want Brenna gone. I can live with anyone else.
I agree about the voice, but there's no guarantee that the best voice will ever sing the best song in the best way with the most pleasing end result. I totally agreed with Simon that her song choice -- and the lack of involvement she had in it -- were not up to par. I always thought Carrie Underwood had a good voice, but I never cared for a single thing she sang.
I have loved Lisa's choices, thus far. Paris is beginning to grate on my nerves. Sweet voice, powerful range. I even love the song she sang last night, Simon be damned. But she started to say something about Bette Midler last night...and she said she sang it, aside from it being her great-grandmother's favorite, because Bette Midler never....and she got cut off. Never? What? Sang it correctly? Could THAT have come out of her mouth? Or...?
At any rate, she left me a bit put off.
Kellie Pickler was sensational. Mandisa was sensational.
I was very disappointed in Heather and Melissa. Kinnik and Breena bit the big ones.
And was anyone else grateful to Simon for chastising Paula for interrupting him and acting like a child? The comments from the judges got so much better AFTER she exchanged seats with Randy. Even Paula became more critical and less gushy in the first seat.
